6 ms·
In a legal document negotiated between parties you don't want to keep track of every version of the file, just the latest version of the offered terms and count
by gamblor956 7y ago
In a legal document negotiated between parties you don't want to keep track of every version of the file, just the latest version of the offered terms and counteroffered terms.
Changes by you are highlighted in one color.
Changes by other parties are highlighted in other colors.
If you need a diff between versions Word can generate one for you in seconds.
So yes, this is exactly how we work. Because it was designed to fit our workflow.
- rickycook 7y agoi’d argue that it’s not “designed to fit our workflow” so much as designed around a subpar, but flexible tool that everyone was using. that don’t make it good; that just makes it ingrained
- mikeryan 7y agoTrack changes in Word works pretty well for turns of a contract. What features do you think are provided by "version control" that aren't handled by Track Changes for contracts?
- sjy 7y agoThe ability to keep track of many, potentially thousands of individual changes and assign labels to significant versions. Track Changes is basically like Git if every file write triggered an automatic commit with no commit message and anyone could rewrite history at any time. SharePoint major versions are better but they’re not free, standard, portable or popular.
- gamblor956 7y agoIf you have a legal agreement with many thousands of changes at any point, someone is getting fired for royally fucking up... Legal agreements are basically a war over each party's choice of standardized language followed by battles over customized terms.
- sjy 7y agoThat may be accurate for commercial contracts but lawyers write lots of other documents too, some of which are subject to thousands of edits. Think about judicial opinions, advices, written arguments, continuously updated legal commentary services, public reports, or indeed statutes. These documents are often carefully drafted over months and complex manual protocols get set up to manage it, due to the limitations of Track Changes and the lack of familiarity with the tools used by software engineers.
- gamblor956 7y agoTrack Changes tracks changes. By multiple authors. And allows comments outside of the substantive content of the document. It works across multiple versions of itself, and is even compatible with competing software. And best of all, it requires no additional software to learn or maintain. That makes it superior for legal documents to all version tracking systems that I'm aware of that are used in the programming field.
- jaredchung 7y agoWell yes, if you constrain the solution set to satisfy "requires no additional software to learn" then you'll end up with the status quo solution. One thing I've always been concerned about when negotiating a legal agreement is how I verify that the tracked changes actually track every change. Because Word lets the user decide which changes to track, I'm always reading the untracked sections as well to confirm that no other changes were sneakily introduced. That's something that git addresses well. Does Word have a solution there? If not, does that ever concern you?
- citizenkeen 7y agoAs a former attorney, I'd just do a diff. Save a copy, reject all changes, then do a diff and compare side by side. As a current software engineer, Word is definitely sufficient (and understood, which sf good) for two small adversarial teams. Key words being small (two huge firms negotiating a huge deal should not be using Word) and adversarial: I think a lot of times when tech-people suggest lawyers could do a better job they forget the other side isn't trying to be helpful.
- osrec 7y agoI agree. Most legal docs could probably be better captured in markdown or asciidoc rather than MS Word (and all the bloat it brings with it).
- nyxtom 7y agoThat’s the entire point of pull requests though? Or am I missing something
- jnny_b 7y ago>In a legal document negotiated between parties you don't want to keep track of every version of the file, just the latest version of the offered terms and counteroffered terms. Not true, at least from the point of view of a litigator. The changes to an agreement can be crucial, especially in the absence of an entire agreement clause. There are, of course, rules about using evidence outside the agreement to construe its meaning, but many exceptions to this rule exist - eg, mistake. The biggest exception is ambiguity, where previous additions/deletions serve to highlight what the parties' intentions were at the time of agreement.
- gamblor956 7y agoAs a former litigator, I have never found a judge willing to accept such evidence into the record.
- ska 7y agoThat would be awfully difficult to have accepted by a judge. Even if it was, proving intent would be very difficult - after all just because you introduced a change doesn't mean I agreed to it. Often contract clauses start off in a "no way I would sign that" state, and may get carried along for a while as you are focused on different things. The fact it existed in the history is, by itself, pretty meaningless.