11 ms·
Not sure why people think long term Tesla is in an amazing position. Their market share can only go down. All of the car companies have or are releasing cars t
by threeseed 7y ago
Not sure why people think long term Tesla is in an amazing position.
Their market share can only go down. All of the car companies have or are releasing cars this year/next and are significantly more capitalised. Some of these cars are superior to Tesla e.g. Porsche Taycan and their ability to share platforms between brands helps to amortise costs.
As we've seen with Summon their FSD program does not look like coming out anytime soon and their inability to be profitable means they can't invest in it or even fundamentals like product refreshes.
- mulcahey 7y agoThey can significantly grow with declining market share if the market for electric cars itself grows significantly. That market is currently < 1% of all cars sold.
- braythwayt 7y agoConsider Apple, which at one time was making more than 50% of the margin in the global market for smartphones, while holding a declining share of unit sales. They did all right. I’m not a huge Tesla fan, but the idea that they might become an enormously profitable company without turning into one of those conglomerates that sells cars at every price point seems reasonable, especially in an age where the margins will be in tech and services rather than in selling steel bent into the shape of a car.
- dv_dt 7y agoMarket share can go down while market size for electric vehicles increases with a positive profit growth for Tesla. But I agree that, as an investment, Tesla stock prices are something the company has to grow into not something that is reflective of in hand performance - and there is always risk there.
- Sohcahtoa82 7y ago> Some of these cars are superior to Tesla e.g. Porsche Taycan Depends on your metrics. IMO, the Model 3 Performance is the superior car. Half the price, quicker, longer range, and has access to the largest fast-charging network in the country.
- xiphias2 7y agoYou didn't even mention efficiency, which means generally slower charging time/km/kW for Taycan. On the other hand Porshe is still luxury brand, so I can imagine the interior being more elegant.
- akimball 7y agoSlow, heavy Volkswagen is my take.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoI think the hope is the Porsche Taycan will be a legitimate track car. Teslas are still known to overheat, and I have yet to find a single example of someone tracking a Tesla for even 5 laps in a row (I am aware of the Model 3 Track mode, but either nobody is using it or it doesn't work). EDIT: Found this article: https://insideevs.com/news/367599/video-tesla-model-3-track-mode-burns-range/ https://insideevs.com/news/367599/video-tesla-model-3-track-... So it is doing significantly better than what I originally stated, although apparently you're only going to get about 30 minutes of driving before you have to recharge. That takes a few minutes with gasoline, and a few hours with electric (at 80% you won't even last the 30 minutes). There are some interesting comments on that article, someone calculates the car will only last about 15 minutes on a really demanding track.
- Sohcahtoa82 7y agoI will definitely concede that Tesla's cooling is insufficient for track use. Track mode pre-cools the batteries when you enable it (among other things), which allows you to go for longer, but it only delays the inevitable. I'm interested to see if the Model S Plaid edition and Roadster 2.0 have better cooling to make them better on a track.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoI think it's just really hard to keep their batteries where they need to be. In order to get better performance/range, Tesla chose NCA batteries. https://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/types_of_lithium_ion https://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/types_of_lithium... The problem with NCA is it is more volatile, and if it overheats it literally explodes violently. I am not saying this is insurmountable, but looking at the progress Tesla is making versus the reality of how long you can drive the cars hard, I think Teslas might never be great track vehicles. Although every EV car will have this problem to some extent, so it's not limited to Tesla. If Porsche can't figure out how to cool an EV well, then it's a long way away because they are famous for their engine cooling technology.
- thorin_2 7y agoNot an owner or shareholder. I encourage you to read up a bit more on their competitive strengths, including their battery, charging infrastructure, and autonomous driving tech. In that regard they are WAY ahead of the competition. I am stoked that VW is serious about playing the EV game, and you are correct that they are significantly more capitalized; however they are still WAY behind Tesla in the critical areas mentioned above. IMO, they are going to gain a lot more market share, for a long time to come.
- dd36 7y agoThe Porsche Taycan is not superior on any metric. Also, they just turned a profit. Did you write this comment before they reported?
- manigandham 7y agoOn any metric? The car reviews disagree. There's a general consensus that Porsche did a great job with a sporty car that appeals to its client base, and benefits from the luxury and build quality experience of the brand.
- dd36 7y agoStyle is subjective. Everywhere else it under performs a Model S and costs twice as much.
- clouddrover 7y ago> Everywhere else it under performs a Model S That isn't the practical reality: https://www.thedrive.com/news/30467/watch-a-porsche-taycan-turbo-s-beat-a-tesla-model-s-p100d-in-a-drag-race https://www.thedrive.com/news/30467/watch-a-porsche-taycan-t... https://www.thedrive.com/news/29946/porsche-taycan-laps-broken-down-tesla-model-s-prototype-at-the-nurburgring https://www.thedrive.com/news/29946/porsche-taycan-laps-brok... A Nissan Leaf can also hunt down the Model S on track: https://insideevs.com/news/359903/video-nissan-leaf-beats-tesla-model-s/ https://insideevs.com/news/359903/video-nissan-leaf-beats-te...
- djrogers 7y ago> A Nissan Leaf can also hunt down the Model S on track: A modified, race prepped, brand new 2019 Leaf beat an old, stock Model S of unspecified mileage. Given how quickly TSLA has been advancing their powertrain and battery tech, leaving those details out is misleading at best.
- clouddrover 7y ago
- Reedx 7y ago> Their market share can only go down. The only way that could be true is if they had 100% of the market. Which is far from the case. Most cars in the global fleet aren't even electric yet, let alone Tesla.
- btilly 7y agoI have been aware for about 20 years that on technology trends, all the car companies will release electric cars somewhere near 2020. And that once they do the agenda of manufacturers and car dealers will be at odds. Manufacturers will want to sell electric because that is the future, and car dealers will want to push gas cars to capture the future maintenance revenue. With the result that manufacturers will find that actually selling those electric cars is an uphill battle. The fact that "near 2020" is now "this year or next" doesn't change the rest of the prediction. I would therefore be willing to take a bet that most traditional car companies will be out of the car business in not very many years. This means that there is a giant market share to be captured by new car brands. Tesla is the best known here. But I would also suggest keeping an eye on the many Chinese brands. I consider, for example, SAIC more of a competitive threat to Telsla than Porsche.
- 205guy 7y agoI think this is a very salient point, about the dealership model being a hindrance. It's like Sears and Amazon, at some point the incumbent leader can't change fast enough and the new market is run by new companies. I do think it will take a long time for the big 3 to die, they will probably go all trucks and big SUVs (as Ford has essentially done already), and leave the car market to EVs. However, I do not think that Tesla will be the big winner. They will be much like Apple and prosper, but Nissan with the Leaf (also Renault with the Zoe in Europe) and now Kia and Hyundai with their small electric SUVs are perfectly placed. They have the big manufacturer experience and millions of miles on their solid EV platforms. They could create an EV Camry/Accord-killer tomorrow--actually, I'm surprised they haven't already. Edited to add: this is buried in the Taycan thread, and I wanted to comment on that too. The Taycan is an awesome car and will give Tesla's model S performance a run for their money. But that's it. Porsche is a niche car-maker, and track enthusiasts a niche of that niche. I suppose that being owned by VW (or is it the other way around) just means the technology and know-how will trickle down into the mass market, but that hasn't happened yet, and Tesla is already there with the Model 3.
- matthewdgreen 7y ago“They could create an EV Camry/Accord-killer tomorrow--actually, I'm surprised they haven't already.” The fact that they haven’t tried is the root of the problem. And, I suspect, the problem that will continue to plague them for at least a few more critical years.
- tigershark 7y agoAll the other car manufacturers are way behind Tesla in pretty much every metric, the most important of which are energy efficiency and safety. Even the much, much more expensive Porsche Taycan S turbo has some margin only in track driving and it will be pretty much destroyed next year by the Tesla S with plaid mode (just looking at the unofficial Nurburgring times) and the new roadster will literally lap it.
- clouddrover 7y ago> it will be pretty much destroyed next year by the Tesla S with plaid mode Why don't Tesla's current cars destroy the Taycan? I think it's fair to say that at this time Tesla's a year behind Porsche in the performance EV stakes. Here are some of the Taycan's performance test results which Tesla has so far been unable to match: - 24 hour endurance run. 3,425 kms covered in 24 hours: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4jSG_10_JRg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4jSG_10_JRg - Onboard video of their 7:42 run at the Nurburgring: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8m31EgQkswg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8m31EgQkswg - Acceleration and handling comparison to the Model S P100D: https://www.thedrive.com/news/30467/watch-a-porsche-taycan-turbo-s-beat-a-tesla-model-s-p100d-in-a-drag-race https://www.thedrive.com/news/30467/watch-a-porsche-taycan-t... - Model S Plaid's Nurburgring results: https://www.thedrive.com/news/29946/porsche-taycan-laps-broken-down-tesla-model-s-prototype-at-the-nurburgring https://www.thedrive.com/news/29946/porsche-taycan-laps-brok... And no onboard video yet from any of Tesla's Nurburgring runs unfortunately. It's also disappointing that Tesla isn't bringing any of its current cars to the Nurburgring. > the new roadster will literally lap it That seems unlikely. To literally lap the Taycan the new Roadster will need to achieve a 3:50 lap time. The current electric lap record is 6:05 held by the Volkswagen ID.R: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c3w3fVS-SgQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c3w3fVS-SgQ And the overall record is 5:19 held by the Porsche 919 Evo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQmSUHhP3ug https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQmSUHhP3ug
- sorenjan 7y agoYou can add the moose handling test to the list: https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/dhsofz/tesla_model_s_vs_porsche_taycan_handling_test/ https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/dhsofz/tesla_m...
- jsight 7y ago> Their market share can only go down. When you currently hold less than 2% of the market, this is far from a certain statement. Their share is as likely to increase as their competitors, though the rate of increase is certainly open to debate. > As we've seen with Summon their FSD program does not look like coming out anytime soon and their inability to be profitable means they can't invest in it or even fundamentals like product refreshes. Considering that both S and X are getting a major drivetrain and battery refresh next year, I don't see how you can say that they aren't investing in product refreshes. I do not have a positive opinion on their FSD efforts, however, I will say one positive thing about their approach. They seem to be accomplishing at least as much as some of their competitors (for example, Ford) with far less capital investment. I see no reason why that trend won't continue.
- paulpauper 7y agoreminds of the same ppl who said in 2003-2013 that competitors to the ipod and then the iPhone have better features or are better. Tesla's value is not just in the features, price, and performance, but also the brand itself.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoOther premium car manufacturers have strong brands as well. Tesla have had the field to themselves for some time, this is clearly going to change over the next couple of years.
- icelancer 7y ago>> Their market share can only go down Are you going to ignore the fact that the market size can only go up?
- hoseja 7y ago"Their market share can only go down.", the FUDder cries while ignoring the fact Tesla created the entire market and it's exploding rapidly.