4 ms·
There is, perhaps, a larger question...There appears to be a large mismatch between public perception of the weight of certain academic badges, and the actual s
by bane 16y ago
There is, perhaps, a larger question...There appears to be a large mismatch between public perception of the weight of certain academic badges, and the actual substance of the badge.
In your example, the Rhodes selection committee selects only people from a particular elite slice of Australian society, yet it may have nothing at all to do with their actual intellectual qualifications, "such exceptional people exist all over Australia".
Yet the public perception is that a Rhodes scholar is somebody who is not only extremely bright, but the top of the tippy top of bright people. They are the medium from which light itself emanates.
You can find this kind of mismatch elsewhere when it comes to similar comparisons of actual intelligence, vs. perceived intelligence a particular badge bestows on a person. "I graduated from Harvard" "I went to Oxford", "The best school is Seoul University" etc. Appears to have only slightly more substance to a person's intelligence and worth than the brand of socks they are wearing. Yet the public will grant significant weight to these things.
Articles like this work to slowly peck away at this often faulty public perception. It's not that Rhodes Scholars, or graduates of top schools aren't smart -- just that similarly smart people exist elsewhere. It's only a matter of time before "Rhodes Scholar" means only slightly more than "Dean's List" in terms of perception.
I'm afraid more and more that badges that should signify significant intellectual achievement are becoming more and more worthless. In order to improve the value of these badges, it behooves the selection committees to cast a wider net and find people from many other places who fit their requirements...doing the hard word of actually finding people than the lazy work of fishing in only well known ponds.
- jacques_chester 16y agoHere's where I contradict myself. Rhodes Scholarships are valuable because they are very rare. According to Wikipedia, the USA got 32 places in 2006, Australia got 9. But given that in a given year, tens of thousands of Australian students could apply in the first instance (having good scores, plays a sport, involved in some other activity). At a statistical level, the distinction between the top 100, the top 50, and the top 10, is going to be nigh on invisible. So in a sense it is just as reasonable to select students from the University of Sydney (prestigious) as from the University of Western Sydney (considered to be a dump). It's just that Sydney University happens to be wired into the Sydney establishment, especially through its residential colleges. And the Sydney establishment is the dominant fraction of the Australian establishment. And the Australian establishment provides the selection committee for the Rhodes scholarships. Being at Sydney means that you have an opportunity to meet some of the selectors, and to get to know them, in advance. That's more or less how our Rhodes Scholar opposition leader, Tony Abbott, got a leg up.
- hugh3 16y agoSo in a sense it is just as reasonable to select students from the University of Sydney (prestigious) as from the University of Western Sydney (considered to be a dump). But there's also self-selection factors. 1. The best students are far more likely to go to Sydney than UWS, because as you mentioned, UWS is a bit of a dump. Of course in fairness UNSW is pretty good, but... 2. The sort of people who are interested in Rhodes Scholarships are exactly the sort of people who are likely to choose Sydney over UNSW. Why? Because Rhodes Scholars are the sort of people who think Oxford is the awesomest place on Earth, and Sydney is basically Oxford Lite. (Declaration of bias: I went to Sydney.)
- jacques_chester 16y agoSure, you might select Sydney over UWS. But students from other Group of 8 universities are pretty bright self-selectors too. Where are the equal number of Rhodes scholars from the Universities of Queensland, Melbourne, Western Australia, New South Wales and Adelaide, the ANU, and Monash? (I went to Sydney too, for 2 years, before depression wrecked my life. Spent 1 year at St Andrews college.)
- hugh3 16y agoMelbourne I'd expect, the others not so much due to the self-selection factors I mentioned ("If you like Oxford's original 11th century gothic architecture you'll love our 19th century copies of Oxford's 11th century gothic architecture!). If there's significantly more from Sydney than Melbourne then, yes, I'd say something is screwy.
- jacques_chester 16y agoI got curious and decided to test my assertion. Taking this list as an input: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Australian_Rhodes_scholars http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Australian_Rhodes_scho... 70 entries in total. I excluded 4 entries where the original university is unknown, and 3 where the person did not attend university in Australia, leaving a sample of 63 scholars. Of the remainders: Sydney: 13 Melbourne: 17 Adelaide: 15 Queensland: 5 UWA: 8 Tasmania: 5 While this is not a representative sample (it depends on Wikipedian "notability"), it may suggest that I am full of shite.