3 ms·
The problem is anyone actually considering whether they should do what they are told has probably at some point wondered whether they should be good students, a
by jerf 16y ago
The problem is anyone actually considering whether they should do what they are told has probably at some point wondered whether they should be good students, and at the Rhodes Scholar level of competition it doesn't take very many semesters of not-straight-As to not be in the running anymore. Selecting for straight-As and the ideal academic is, to be fair, selecting for exactly the kind of person the author decries.
I'm not saying no straight-A student is a thinker, just that at some point a thinker has probably found some reason to end up not getting straight-As for a semester. Maybe not even a good reason. Just a reason.
- hugh3 16y agoTo get a Rhodes scholarship, you don't just have to do well academically, you also need to be an enthusiastic sportsman and participate in a bunch of extracurricular activities -- i.e. be an obsessive CV-builder. And indeed, since the actual cash value of a Rhodes scholarship isn't all that large, the main reason to want one is to get another shiny achievement for your already-extensive CV to impress even more people. The kind of students who are competitive for Rhodes scholarships are thus exactly the sort of students who do things in order to build up their CVs rather than because they are particularly passionate about them. A Rhodes scholarship selection committee member complaining that kids nowadays are thoughtless hardworking achievement drones is like a football coach complaining that students nowadays spend too much time in the gym. It may or may not be true in general, but it's obviously true of the subset you're interacting with.
- jacques_chester 16y agoIt's also a reinforcing spiral. Getting into a Model UN conference at high school, improves your chances of joining the state debate team, which improves your chances of getting into an honours society, which improves your chances of going to that Future Leaders seminar, which ... I called it "The CV circuit". The only way to win was to get onto it first. I think Americans have worked this out more completely than we have (in New York they send toddlers to prep school to get them into the best kindergartens).