3 ms·
See the comments on Kalai's post from Peter Shor, where Kalai attempts to address this, and my reply to mantap on this thread where I try to give my poor unders
by andrewla 7y ago
See the comments on Kalai's post from Peter Shor, where Kalai attempts to address this, and my reply to mantap on this thread where I try to give my poor understanding of the critique.
- raverbashing 7y agoI'll just say the line between being unfairly critical and raising valid points seem to be a very thin one. Especially when Peter Shore is disagreeing with the critique (and I agree with him). Saying that a quantum computation does not qualify because it included (a short) classic computation does not seem a fundamentally fair criticism to me.