3 ms·
> That assumes a benevolent government. Rules can change because of balance-of-power shifts, or as a result of misinformed debates. that's true in any jurisdic
by gpderetta 7y ago
> That assumes a benevolent government. Rules can change because of balance-of-power shifts, or as a result of misinformed debates.
that's true in any jurisdiction, right? Laws and regulations can always override contracts.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> that's true in any jurisdiction, right? Laws and regulations can always override contracts. What varies is how easily new rules can be introduced, how easily they can be challenged, and the number of entities with rule making power. Broadly speaking, Europe's systems make it easy for rules to be introduced and hard for them to be struck down by a competing arm of government. There also tend to be more regulators with independent rule making authority in Europe than in America. This derives, fundamentally, from differing levels of trust in government, and differing views on the scope of government's job.
- gpderetta 7y agoThe rule (i.e. the GDPR law) was introduced by the european commission and parliament. It is applied by the various regulating agencies, interpreted by the courts and ultimately by the ECJ. It is not like that governmental agencies are making up rules.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> It is applied by the various regulating agencies I was making a broad statement about rule making processes in the Europe (EU and member states) versus Europe. That said, GDPR is independently interpreted by each of the EU's member states. It is a complain-investigate regime that does not bind one member state to the other's precedents. That's a lot of leeway for regulatory variance.
- gpderetta 7y agodivergence of rule interpretation is an issue, and harmonization is is the role of the ECJ (as final arbiter of interpretation) and ultimately the European legislative branch (for further harmonization). Still, I do not see you go from that to "[it is] easy for rules to be introduced and hard for them to be struck down ". edit: remember, the alternative is 28 potentially incompatible rules.