3 ms·
Hi, > Your claim that steam/sony/microsoft all charge 30% no negotiations is dated if not completely inaccurate I get the general impression that you're eithe
by dijit 7y ago
Hi,
> Your claim that steam/sony/microsoft all charge 30% no negotiations is dated if not completely inaccurate
I get the general impression that you're either in a much better bargaining position than I am, or you're not in the industry.
I still make AAA games, the latest of which came out this year[0] I can tell you concretely that we pay 30% of every purchase to the first party.
(except on PC, because we sell on uPlay and the Epic store, which has lower fees -- one of steams conditions is that you cant offer the game cheaper elsewhere, so we could never apply discounts on uplay)
> we know for a fact Valve offers a lower cut to big studios now
Valve has been openly hostile to my publisher for many years, perhaps this is the problem? Frequently unlisting our games.[1] We as a publisher do not officially respond to these things because they have better customer relations and a higher sentiment than we do, we would lose a PR battle, so we accept it and move on. This happens in negotiations too.
> I would be shocked if the Playstation or XBox business wings were unwilling to negotiate a cut down in order to land a big, million-selling title
They have almost all the power in those negotiations. The only bargaining power we have is if we have a very strongly rated title that we threaten to make exclusive. But in those cases we would lose more from _not_ selling on the platform than we would make back in the first-party cut. So it's lose-lose.
30% applies to in-game consumables too, anything processed by them as a payment provider.
What games company do you work for? :)
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Clancy%27s_The_Division_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Clancy%27s_The_Division_2
[1]: https://kotaku.com/ubisoft-pulls-big-games-from-steam-1655676773 https://kotaku.com/ubisoft-pulls-big-games-from-steam-165567...
- baud147258 7y agoPerhaps your games on Steam would be better received if they didn't force the buyer to also install a crapware like Uplay on top of Steam and forcing to create another user account to play a game the buyer has just paid for (perhaps it has changed, I haven't bought an Ubi game in years).
- dijit 7y agoRegarding a second account; I'm afraid there's very little that can be done on that front, there was account linking added some time ago that meant you didn't need to maintain or continually log-in to uplay, you just create a linked account and forget about it- no second password needed I believe. So at least for usability it should not be any different than normal. If you have other specific complaints about uPlay then I'd be happy to hear them and feed them back to the team, since we're actually located in the same studio. Unfortunately uPlay does drive a significant amount of business value, handling things like entitlements so that each game doesn't have to re-implement them and allowing us to handle things like distribution of "other" types of clients, like development versions of the games for review, or debug enabled versions of games for debugging. It also allows for A/B testing of various features. As recently as 2017 there was consensus among ubisoft upper management that the perception of uPlay was bad, so more focus has been put on the user aspects, so in theory it should be much better now than it was, because before it was very business focused. But, as everything, people are happy to help if they can, nobody wants to make an awful system. Unless the problem is that you have to have a second launcher? that's usually peoples primary complaint. (and in those cases uPlay tries to hide itself and stay out of the way)
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoWell, I can assure you that seeing a game requires uPlay means I'm probably not going to buy it, and I'm not alone in that. Of course, I haven't even wanted to play an Ubisoft game since... I honestly can't remember, so I guess I'm not the target audience anyway. > Unless the problem is that you have to have a second launcher? That's a big part of it. I have enough crapware that insists on constantly running on my PC (a lot of it direct from MS these days, sigh). PS: Oh yeah, and it wants me to sign up for an account too. Hooray! I don't have enough of accounts spread all over the goddamned place already.
- dijit 7y agoSo, again, the largest complaint is that we have our own launcher. Given what I mentioned from the parent (Valve arbitrarily pulling down all our games), how do you think I can convince the business to make ourselves more vulnerable to such behaviour?