4 ms·
Science is all about gathering data. Theorise all you like; but if the theory can't be tied back to data at some point in time then it is at best maths or philo
by roenxi 7y ago
Science is all about gathering data. Theorise all you like; but if the theory can't be tied back to data at some point in time then it is at best maths or philosophy.
Experiments and dispassionate language are about gathering clear data and representing it accurately. Claiming that science is all about "clarity and economy" is ironically unscientific - if nature is unclear and uneconomical then good science has to represent that too. That part of science isn't taught as much because it takes longer to communicate. Ignoring data, such as from your senses, is also not a good scientific idea.
Being unscientific is ignoring data. There are different standards and a bit of judgement about what quality of data and how relevant it is, but ultimately the person with the most relevant and comprehensive data on a subject is the 'truest' scientist in a very meaningful way.
- username90 7y agoCreating theories helps guide us towards collecting the right data. For example nobody would have checked Mercury's precession unless Einstein had suggested the theory of general relativity. That is what good science is, first you predict and then verify, not first get data and then make models to fit said data.
- roenxi 7y agoAssuming we agree that there is an objective reality; someone who figures out truths by measuring then fitting is obviously doing science. The phenomenon studied by science are largely those that are real no matter how they are approached. There are easier and harder ways to come up with useful data and I endorse predict -> check-> refine as a great model; but if someone figured out laws by guessing what data they needed to gather then did a curve fit doesn't somehow make the laws invalid or the process particularly unscientific. If someone had just gotten lucky and just happened to plot mass vs velocity to recover the laws of gravity we'd still include it in all the science textbooks. What is the alternative - claim they figured out universal truths in the wrong way and ignore them until someone else figures it out? If all the data fits the model then science has happened. Everything else is quibbling how robust the data is (which is still important).
- diffeomorphism 7y ago> someone who figures out truths by measuring then fitting is obviously doing science. No, the point is that is the wrong way around. Given any big amount of data you are going to find something that fits, e.g https://www.xkcd.com/882/ https://www.xkcd.com/882/ . You are not "predicting" anything if you come up with your fit afterwards. You can however use the fit you got to try to predict the outcome of future experiments. Checking that those experiments fit is science.
- roenxi 7y agoThere is no such thing as 'the right way round' when dealing with things that have been true for longer than the human species has existed and will continue to be true after the last human is dust. There are things that are true and things that are not, and we do our best to figure out what ideas get classified in which side of that hard boundary. We can agree on standards of evidence, but at the end of the day one can be scientific without being rigorous. The XKCD comic isn't making a judgement on whether the characters in it are or are not scientists - in fact, it calls them scientists - it is pointing out that statistical significance is a low bar of evidence and best treated with suspicion.
- dariosalvi78 7y ago> Given any big amount of data you are going to find something that fits Exactly, and that's the main problem at the base of all "data mining": it is probable that you will find a model that will only work with your data. Take a step outside and everything falls. You are basically giving a formula to noise. But often discoveries happen also by chance, so we shouldn't stop looking at unexpected patterns. However, once you find one, you should create a theory to explain it and setup a new experiment to confirm your theory. If you can....
- username90 7y ago> If someone had just gotten lucky and just happened to plot mass vs velocity to recover the laws of gravity we'd still include it in all the science textbooks. I am not so sure it would have been a hit as a stand alone formula. Newton discovered calculus and used it to lay the groundwork for almost the entire field of physics, gravity was just a minor detail in his work. Or if you are talking about General relativity, there is no way people would have discovered it from observations alone, we'd get some kind of correction term explanation similar to dark matter or dark energy since the formula is extremely complicated. It is even possible that most physicists would have accepted those corrections as the correct solution and would be looking for the new dark particles inside of large stars for a hundred years before someone corrected them. Or the discovery of black holes would be seen as evidence of these particles, cementing our ignorance forever.
- sgt101 7y agoI agree, but there are two problems. First; a point made in the article - the breadth of data available in many domains (economics, business, medicine, psychology, linguistics, biology, and more) is vast and unmanageable. An a-priori selection made by the attention of the investigator misdirects us. Additionally some data is not captured due to process problems, a classic is missed opportunity in business. You advocate focus on new business opportunities, I advocate focus on our old markets - I show that by treating our current customers differently a 5% reduction in cost is possible. You claim a 50% revenue opportunity, but how do you know? I can claim a causal link, you are claiming hypotheticals. I win the argument and then a year later we examine the data - I have achieved the cost saving, and there is no record of all the business that we didn't get. The opportunity loss is not on the spreadsheet. Conversely if you win and we look a year later I can show that our customers still cost us what they did, and I can show (if you were successful) that my initiative would have saved 7.5% of the spend one year ago (+50% thanks to you). Problem two; outside physics and chemistry not many things are comparable in the sense that statistics expects them to be. This is closely related to the scope of data problem, but hides it. Widgets made by machines or seeds carefully selected and screened can be made to share (approximately) an identity so that they can be statistically reasoned about in bulk. Other things can't and medicine is really running up against this now. Pain killers work differently on people with different genetics and different genders (also different ages, contexts...) Cancer evolves differently from case to case. The assumption of similarity and category membership is often broken and we often do not notice before doing a t-test.
- paganel 7y ago> Experiments and dispassionate language are about gathering clear data and representing it accurately And then you get into a philosophical discussion about what represents "clear data" (not to mention the "representing it accurately" part, which imho it's an issue we've been trying to solve for at least 2500 years and haven't progressed too much in doing it).
- brnt 7y agoScience isn't all about data, just like how apple pie isn't all about apples. They are essential ingredients, but there are other ingredients that are no less essential. W.r.t. some branches of science (medical), I'd say data isn't the biggest ingredient lacking. Most of it is correlational, which is an easy way to use data; you're just looking for correlations and that's about it. It however doesn't provide a lot of insight into fundamentals: it doesn't answer 'how?'. It's modelling that is often lacking: how does this data, this correlation support or disprove certain theories, in order to advance our understanding as a whole rather than being able to say 'medicine X provides Y% improvement in property Z. In my view, particle physics is a branch of science doing this very well: data is never used without context, correlations never made without some sort of theoretical framework.
- naringas 7y ago> Science is all about gathering data. isn't it about the replication of experiments? you can gather all the data you want, but if you can't repeat an experiment to get the same data, then I don't think all your data qualifies as science.