4 ms·
> California is sucking more and more with time. Why is this, and how do we get it fixed? Shouldn't this sort of burden be the same throughout the US?
by echelon 7y ago
> California is sucking more and more with time.
Why is this, and how do we get it fixed? Shouldn't this sort of burden be the same throughout the US?
- lwhalen 7y agoNope, California has been the poster-child for Big Government for _decades_. Each year the State regularly spawns off several tens of thousands of folks who have 'had enough', who migrate to Small(er)-Government states, and then promptly start advocating for the exact kinds of policies that made them leave CA in the first place. It's a stereotype at this point, especially in places like Washington, Oregon, Texas, Montana, etc.
- t34543 7y agoThe state of cancer causes California
- robomartin 7y agoThat's the part I don't understand. Why do people leave CA and then push for the same policies? It's crazy. I don't get it.
- lwhalen 7y agoI suspect it's a flaw in how humans (of certain political persuasions) rationalize "how we got here". They think "Well, the old place was OK except for this very small bit that pushed me over the edge into 'move elsewhere' territory. Now this new place is OK, but if we just enacted this little bit of legislation to be more like the place I just came from...." That in and of itself would be fine if it was extremely limited. However, when it's tens of thousands of people, and they all have different ideas of what "this little bit" that needs to change is, it's a recipe for the behavior we see now. Incidentally, this pattern is where a lot of conservative commentators are coming from when they say "liberalism is a disease". Non-liberals don't tend to exhibit this behavior - they move to an area, hunker down, shut up, and try to integrate.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Non-liberals don't tend to exhibit this behavior - they move to an area, hunker down, shut up, and try to integrate. I'm not sure what definition of “liberal” you are using, but there are so many obvious counterexamples that don't fit any of the plausoble ones that I can't see any way that that could be even a useful rule of thumb. Missionaries tend not to be liberals, and indeed tend to be lionized by conservatives for doing exactly the opposite of “move to an area, hunker down, shut up, and try to integrate.” Conservatives don't object to liberals because liberals proselytize more than conservatives, they object to liberals because liberals disagree with conservatives.
- lwhalen 7y agoThat is a fair counterexample that I didn't consider. I don't know why you're getting downvoted to oblivion on it. Thanks for making your point!
- robomartin 7y agoThe term "liberal" in the US has lost it's meaning. What we often call "liberals" in the US are more like "leftists" than the traditional liberal way of life and thought. Classical Liberalism if very, very far from what the Democratic party pushes these days. In fact, I would venture a guess that most thinking people are Classical Liberals. I make the distinction about "thinking" people not to be elitists at all, but rather because it is obvious that there are those who blindly follow and then there are those who choose to be more analytical and actually think rather than follow. Problems, as Einstein famously said, cannot be solved from the state of mind that created them in the first place. This is where, I think, Classical Liberalism fits. I happen to think it is an ideology that would do the most good and deliver the greatest benefits across the board. In case someone reading this isn't clear on the distinction, here's a good explanation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iU-8Uz_nMaQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iU-8Uz_nMaQ
- dragonwriter 7y ago> What we often call "liberals" in the US are more like "leftists" than the traditional liberal way of life and thought. Originally, the political Left was a name for classical liberalism based on where the liberals sat, as opposed to the conservative monarchists, in the French National Assembly. So if we’re fetishizing the original sense of terms, the distinction is nonsense. Most of the political spectrum in the modern West (outside of the far right, which is classically conservative) is rooted in classical liberalism, which was nearly completely victorious over classical conservatism. They differ in whether they see the progress made by the 18th century liberals as the end goal or the starting point (“Left” evolved somewhat faster than “liberal” because that division became evident during the revolutionary period in France.) > I make the distinction about "thinking" people not to be elitists at all Yeah, you just think disagreeing with you ideologically can only be possible if people don't think. > but rather because it is obvious that there are those who blindly follow and then there are those who choose to be more analytical and actually think rather than follow. Sure, that much is true. The part that's less obvious is where you say most everyone that falls in the latter camp agrees with you ideologically while most everyone who disagrees with you is in the former camp.
- varjag 7y agoWell in this case, it appears the county permits dept knows what they are doing, and the poster doesn't. Can't see what has to be fixed.
- robomartin 7y agoHow so? Why do you assume I don't know what I am doing?
- robomartin 7y ago> Why is this, and how do we get it fixed? Not to get political on HN, but, well, California is now in the grips of a truly demented ideology. Due to having overwhelming majority everywhere, they can pretty much do as they wish. It's as close to a corrupt third world government as I hope we are ever going to get. For example, our roads are in terrible shape. They have squandered or diverted funds that were specifically allocated to road maintenance. By that I mean: We voted to pass measures to collect additional taxes to fix the roads and they stole the money. Another interesting one: They pushed and passed a law taxing any square foot of land that does not allow a drop of rain water to directly make contact with dirt. The tax is $0.025 per square foot. This means that your home, driveway, patio, patio cover, etc. are counted as part of this. Think of places like your local mall, Home Depot or strip malls, where 95% of the dirt is covered. This is huge. I could go on. Like the high speed train to nowhere that we approved at a cost of $10 billion that is now near or past $100 billion. It goes nowhere, it isn't finished and nobody is gong to use it. And yet they don't stop. I would not be surprised if this becomes a half billion dollar project. The ROI on these things is so upside-down a fifth-grader could figure out it's a bad deal. And, of course, there's this: https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidblackmon/2019/10/10/californias-high-gasoline-prices-are-no-accident/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidblackmon/2019/10/10/califo... And this: https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertwood/2019/10/22/now-california-can-assess-taxes-no-matter-where-you-livereally/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertwood/2019/10/22/now-calif...
- CamperBob2 7y agoWhich is why it's so important for the, er, loyal opposition party to clean its own house. If the party in question poisons its brand to an extent that keeps them out of power for generations -- which is what they've already done in California and are busy trying to do everywhere else -- we will all end up worse off for it. The only thing worse than a two-party system is a de facto one-party system.
- ranDOMscripts 7y agore the rain tax: if that means the mall owner has to open up some of those acres of asphalt to reduce stormwater runoff or landlords end up jackhammering the cement slabs covering the front and backyards (because spraying herbicide a couple times a year is way cheaper/easier than regular gardening service) then I fail to see the problem. Your giant slabs of cementitious landscaping are contributing to my heat island effect so the tax is a small reminder to rip the unnecessary bits out and plant a couple trees instead.