3 ms·
Eh, I guess any proof is circular, but it is, IMO, "more" circular when the thing we're trying to prove was one of the preconditions of how we defined the syste
by mlyle 7y ago
Eh, I guess any proof is circular, but it is, IMO, "more" circular when the thing we're trying to prove was one of the preconditions of how we defined the system--- properties that we wanted to obtain a priori.
It's like defining negative exponents based on the properties we want for commutation, identity, etc... and then afterwards proving that something raised to a negative exponent times something raised to a positive exponent is 1 and patting ourselves on the back.
- jacobolus 7y ago> thing we're trying to prove was one of the preconditions This entirely depends on what you consider to be a definition of the dot product. There are many possible ways this could be set up. (e.g. if you wanted you could develop this whole theory of vector algebra within the system of Euclid’s axioms. Or you could set it up based on explicit coordinates and concrete arithmetic of numbers with no geometrical basis per se. Or ...) The hard work leading up to this proof is showing that the algebraic definition a·b = 0 corresponds to the usual notion of perpendicularity in Euclidean space. After that, the algebraic proof of the Pythagorean identity is trivial.