3 ms·
If I'm reading the report correctly, the bridge was barely sufficient to support its own weight, which is extremely surprising since I remember reading a very l
by userbinator 7y ago
If I'm reading the report correctly, the bridge was barely sufficient to support its own weight, which is extremely surprising since I remember reading a very long time ago that bridges and other structures are designed to be 10x stronger than they normally need to be; a vague reference in the article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factor_of_safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factor_of_safety supports that. It seems like this bridge was designed for minimal cost...
- sitharus 7y agoThis is totally hearsay, but I've heard from multiple older engineers that as computer models have been improved over time the safety factor has been reduced as we have more accurate simulations. If the safety factors from the '50s had been used it's possible this bridge would never have been designed the way it was.
- dredmorbius 7y agoI've noticed from videos of recent bridge failures (FIU and the Taiwain Arch Bridge collapse a few weeks ago) how fast the failures occur. Contrast with, say, the Tacoma Narrows bridge failure in the 1940s. I suspect current designs are far nearer critical tolerances. Even under the ridiculous dynamics of the Tacoma Narrows incident, ultimate failure took hours.
- userbinator 7y agoEven under the ridiculous dynamics of the Tacoma Narrows incident, ultimate failure took hours. It took 4 months from construction to failure, during which time it was already flexing far more than normal.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThe FIU and Taiwan's Nanfang'ao Bridge collapse (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanfang%27ao_Bridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanfang%27ao_Bridge) each precipitated in seconds. Contrast Tacoma Narrows, whose final throes were long enough for crowds to form and traffic to be cleared. Tacoma: https://youtube.com/watch?v=mXTSnZgrfxM https://youtube.com/watch?v=mXTSnZgrfxM FIU: https://youtube.com/watch?v=BSq8295GFk4 https://youtube.com/watch?v=BSq8295GFk4 Nanfang'ao: https://youtube.com/watch?v=mjsZbbG5fag https://youtube.com/watch?v=mjsZbbG5fag Morandi, Genoa, Italy: https://youtube.com/watch?v=_gEMep8xLHk https://youtube.com/watch?v=_gEMep8xLHk I-35W, Minneapolis, MN: https://youtube.com/watch?v=74JNl5n-YdI https://youtube.com/watch?v=74JNl5n-YdI
- jaclaz 7y agoThe (approximate) rule of the thumb is that anything in reinforced concrete calculated by "hand" has an "implied" additional safety factor of 5-10%, mainly due to roundings by excess in the calculations, at least this has been my experience in the mid 1990's, when for a couple of bridges existing hand made calculations had been re-made with computers. It is a small (but good) thing, though it would have IMHO not been enough to save this particular bridge, here the issue is evidently a wrong static model, or - less likely - a wrong assessment of loads. Besides the initial (huge) calculation error, what is really preoccupying is that they didn't consider as serious the cracks, which as seen in the video/photos on youtube are the typical (severe) shear cracks, that should have been ringing all alarms. The poor structure, as often happens, did all it could to "signal" the issue, what I find bordering being criminal is ignoring or severely underestimating those clear signals.
- catalogia 7y agoEngineers are taught that anybody can design a bridge, but only a skilled engineer can design a bridge that barely stands. https://hn.algolia.com/?query=bridge%20that%20barely%20stands&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=bridge%20that%20barely%20stand...
- jaclaz 7y agoNo, bridges (usually, but it depends on countries/national regulations and on the nature of the structure) have an overall design factor of safety between 1.2 and 1.8, in some cases 2, but the actual presumed loads are already increased (i.e. the calculation loads are more than what will actually happen) and there are some "implicit" safety factors in the use of materials, so that the overall "real" factor of safety usually is between 2 and 3. The highest required factor of safety in engineering is AFAIK 5 and is used for things like lifts, cablecars and similar.
- abduhl 7y agoFactor of safety in the way that most people understand it has gotten increasing difficult to tease out since the switch to load and resistance factor design (LRFD) over allowable stress design (ASD) for most structures. I think timber is the only one which still defaults to ASD for permanent construction. But the short version of the story is that for LRFD there are two main factors which affect “factor of safety” in the traditional sense (eg - structural capacity / structural demand) which are load factors and resistance factors (as you’d guess). Load factors increase applied forces while resistance factors decrease assumed strengths. Load factors vary depending on the type of load but typically they’re between 1.2 to 1.6. Resistance factors vary based on failure mechanism under consideration and are between 0.6 to 0.9 for structural work. So the range is 1.2/0.9 to 1.6/0.6 or ~1.35 to ~2.75. There are secondary sources of additional factors of safety. For example, material properties assumed in design are the minimums that are allowed and so chances are you’ll get something on site that exceeds by 25-50% or so because nobody wants to deliver material that doesn’t meet the minimums and open themselves to claims liability. There’s also a redundancy factor which is touched on in the report where loads are increased if no redundant load path exists, for concrete there’s some additional caps/limitations on a couple values due to time effects like creep, etc. I would say most modern construction has an overall factor of safety of 3-5 with bleeding edge construction sitting at around 2 and public works construction (utilities or highways - things where architects aren’t involved) at over 5.