4 ms·
I could have omitted Trotsky's ideological proclivities, and simply mentioned that describing him as an intellectual given his responsibility in perpetuating ma
by CryptoPunk 7y ago
I could have omitted Trotsky's ideological proclivities, and simply mentioned that describing him as an intellectual given his responsibility in perpetuating mass murder is obscene.
As for the positive/negative connotations of the term intellectual, I would respectfully disagree. No one describes recognized mass murderers as intellectuals, at least not that I'm aware of, and certainly would never limit their description of such a person to merely an intellectual. It would be intellectually irresponsible to not also mention their crimes. It's this lack of recognition that I took issue with. I hope me mentioning that in the future without mentioning ideology wouldn't be deemed as violating HackerNews guidelines.
- dang 7y agoPerhaps we're running into a usage mismatch about how we understand the same word. That often gets affected by cultural differences too. Just please avoid flamebait and flamewars on HN and especially ideological battle. Those things are not what HN is for, and they destroy what it is for, so we have to be proactive about them.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoJust please avoid flamebait and flamewars on HN and especially ideological battle Yes understood.