3 ms·
So, the Hill already expects "The Next War", do they? Who's going to get it this time? Or - is it Israel's next war, another invasion of one of its neighbors an
by einpoklum 7y ago
So, the Hill already expects "The Next War", do they? Who's going to get it this time? Or - is it Israel's next war, another invasion of one of its neighbors and a pulverization of civilians, housing and infrastructure?
The author explains how "The Israel Defense Forces ... handpicks the best and brightest graduating high schoolers ... and converts them into cyber warriors"
Yeah, great, that's just what a society needs, right? Brainwashing teenagers into supporting, and fighting, wars? And don't forget - it's conscription, not volunteer service in Israel.
The author then goes on to explain how the elite of the Israeli economy comes out of the ranks of those war-minded youths, not from civilian society; and how perpetual war is also reinforced by a continuing close bond between the military and the private sector.
And this is the model Mr. Zakheim, and the Hill, suggest for future US society. To those US'ers among the readers: Please reject that sad vision.
- ksaj 7y ago> Brainwashing teenagers into supporting, and fighting, wars? Isn't it more or less a different version of Air/Army/Sea Cadets? Those begin at age 13 instead of waiting for graduation.
- einpoklum 7y agoRemember that the Israeli military is 5.5x larger, per capita, than the US military - and the 3rd largest in the world (per capita) after Eritrea and North Korea. So you'd need to scale those programs (which I didn't know about actually) up a lot to have something equivalent.
- dogma1138 7y agoThe odd thing is that Israel’s lesson learned form the 2nd Lebanon war was that boots on the ground win wars. It found major shortcomings in its capabilities due to reliance on its Air Force as the go to solution for any problem and the emphasis on counter insurgency and essentially border security when it came to its ground forces made them unable to perform as well as expected in modern combined arms warfare. Their solution was to restructure all of their reservist battalions, put emphasis on combined ground operations when it came to training institute new large scale military exercises each year in order to have an effective ground force which is capable of taking over and effectively controlling territory something that the IDF forgot how to do. Their opinion was that all the intelligence and smart bombs in the world can’t decisively win an engagement, only ground troops can. So in the coming war especially against a conventional or semi conventional force the US still has the advantage of being the ones who wrote the book on maneuver and combined arms warfare and having what is without a doubt the best trained and equipped professional army in the world.
- thrower123 7y agoThere's a bit of interview from an old History Channel documentary that has always stuck in my head. Sadly, I think the source is lost to the mists of time; this was back in the Roger Mudd era when there were no rednecks, Jesus, or Ancient Aliens on the lineup. Maybe a Modern Marvels on future weapons... But in any case, they were interviewing a crusty old veteran of WW1, and he said something to the effect of "You can have all the planes and tanks and new gizmos, but you're still going to have some poor bastard in the mud to winkle the other poor bastard out of his foxhole and make him sign the armistice."