3 ms·
> a new Harold Lloyd is unthinkable because physical comedy depends on the proximity and possibility of death I don't agree with that. Gwyneth Paltrow is amaz
by carapace 7y ago
> a new Harold Lloyd is unthinkable because physical comedy depends on the proximity and possibility of death
I don't agree with that.
Gwyneth Paltrow is amazing at physical comedy. I can't remember the movie but there's a scene where she's getting out of a cab and she just falls over and it's friggin' hilarious. No death in sight.
Certainly death, properly appreciated, is funny. The only thing more absurd than death is sex.
The reason physical comedy is so physically dangerous is that, generally, it's only funny if you go for it and that naturally causes injuries. Like playing football, or WWE wrestling. Half-assing it isn't going to be entertaining.
- synlatexc 7y agoSeconded. To me physical comedy is about physicality: the body, its gestures and movements. Can it involve pain or the possibility of death? Sure, but that's not essential. I was always a fan of John Ritter in Three's Company. He'd flail about in every episode, almost falling or tripping or just making crazy expressions with his face.
- nkrisc 7y agoI find Jackie Chan's physical comedy to be superb. It also doubles as incredible fight scenes. His fight scenes and stunts are riddled with humor.
- QuesnayJr 7y agoKaitlin Olson did a very funny pratfall on It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia that ends with her running full-speed into the door of a taxi. Part of what makes it funny is that it's so real, but she had to regularly see a chiropractor after that.
- XorNot 7y agoWhile I believe she may have suffered genuine impairment, chiropractors are charlatans who's entire business model is signing you up for a recurring treatment plan. They are not physiotherapists, who actually practice useful rehabilitation.
- paxys 7y ago"Possibility of death" is terrible wording, but I generally agree with the statement. A big draw for the old timey sketches used to be "how did they do it?!", even though the audience was aware that the performers weren't literally an inch away from death. Today it would just be written off as mediocre CGI.
- cafard 7y agoAttributed to Sid Caesar: Comedy is you falling down an open manhole and dying. Tragedy is me getting a paper cut.