2 ms·
To be honest, I do personally think score voting comes the closest to what is truly most democratic and accurate, even better than Borda. I hesitate to recomme
by crazygringo 7y ago
To be honest, I do personally think score voting comes the closest to what is truly most democratic and accurate, even better than Borda.
I hesitate to recommend it, however, because I'm not entirely convinced it's intuitive enough for the average voter to understand and apply properly. I'm also afraid it's too open to criticism of seeming overly "subjective", though I personally don't think it is.
I would be very, very, very happy to have evidence that my fears are unfounded, however.
- contravariant 7y agoThe one thing I find iffy about score voting (or range voting) is that there's a decent chance people will just score everyone 5~8. This would give more voting power to people that deliberately only use 0 and 10. So I'd advocate approval voting. Just vote for the options that you find acceptable, the option with the highest acceptance rate wins.
- pgcj_poster 7y ago> there's a decent chance people will just score everyone 5~8 That sounds incredibly unlikely to me. I don't think I know anyone who would rank both Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton as a 7. To the contrary, it seems like people will almost always put either 0 or 10, making it not much different from approval voting.
- contravariant 7y agoThat is a rather extreme example, but still I don't think many people will actually fill in a 0, plenty of 2s and 3s maybe. Besides, like you said, if everyone always puts either 0 or 10 then it's the same thing as approval voting anyway so it can't hurt to just use approval voting.