3 ms·
It's unjust, particularly because "being a Nigerian in Nigeria" is not a condition that most people in that condition can simply elect to remove themselves from
by barrkel 16y ago
It's unjust, particularly because "being a Nigerian in Nigeria" is not a condition that most people in that condition can simply elect to remove themselves from. Consider the situation from a Rawlsian veil of ignorance perspective.
- cturner 16y agoThis is a broader issue than access to Paypal. There's lots of reasons it's not great to be a Nigerian in Nigeria - fixed elections, corruption, violence, low standard of living, tension between the north and south, nasty tropical diseases, relatively lower education opportunities, weak arts community, flowover from ethnic tension in neighbouring states. In the scale of things, concern over ability to make internet payments is probably pretty low, and a concern that would be pressing only to a small elite in the country.
- barrkel 16y agoFrankly, I agree. The thrust of my comment was more on backing up the assertion that treating Nigerians this way is actually unjust, immoral; not that it doesn't make business sense, or that it's a relatively small slice of the larger pie, etc.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI'm guessing there is all sorts of online commerce you don't engage in due to the risk of scams. Is that also unjust, due to the fact that your attempts to avoid a scam might deprive some legitimate people of your business?
- barrkel 16y agoThat's a distinctly different question, for several reasons. (1) Concentration of power: there's a qualitative difference between a large organization making an absolute and sustained decision on a corporate basis, and many distributed small organizations or individuals making ad-hoc iterated decisions on a case by case basis. Normal statistical variation means that in all likelihood, the market will simply be smaller, not all but extinguished. (2) Your guess may be incorrect: I find it difficult to recollect an attempted online commercial transaction that I aborted owing to fear of a scam. Now, if you knew my personal circumstances, perhaps you'd be able to direct my attention to such cases; in lieu of that, can you be more specific in your guess, and at least give me a few examples? A few points on my behaviour: it's my personal policy never to buy anything in direct response to any advertisement or inducement, whether in person, over the phone, via email, or online, if I do not have a prior independent non-commercial relationship with that entity. I will pay more for a service or product that I have found myself rather than accept a similar service or product for a lower price if that service or product was directly advertised to me; I infer that the extra expenses in reaching me directly will be more than recouped via means that are not immediately obvious to me, such that the savings are probably illusory. Any time I have ever engaged in online commerce, it directly or indirectly started out with a Google search for the product or product category in question, or for a store name found either in a previous search, by recommendation, or an online version of a brick-and-mortar store. (3) Freedom of action and the rewards to that action: most Nigerians in Nigeria have little scope for changing their situation to evade these policies; from the original position, I would not like to be in their situation. In converse, the problem of not being able to find customers is distinctly different: one may choose to sell something else, to a different market, and via a different medium. One of the risks of creating a business is that there may not be a viable market, but one of the rewards is profit when the market is viable. The risk / reward correspondence with consumers doesn't seem convincing: at best, the consumer can obtain what they wanted at a fair price; the upside is very limited.
- quanticle 16y agoTry explaining that perspective to your spouse after you lose money in a 419 scam. "But honey, I didn't know that this Nigerian was a con-artist. I had to give him a chance!"
- barrkel 16y agoYou know, this is exactly the same reasoning (prejudice on the basis of generalizing a correlation between a behaviour and a shared attribute) as exhibited by racists. In the same way as it is not fair to discriminate against black people on the basis of a higher relative proportion of criminal convictions, it is similarly not fair to discriminate on the basis of someone being a Nigerian in Nigeria on the basis of 419 scam incidence. That's not to say it may not be effective, on average, in limiting losses. But effectiveness is something distinct from fairness.
- jacquesm 16y ago> That's not to say it may not be effective, on average, in limiting losses. But effectiveness is something distinct from fairness. As long as businesses will be required to eat the losses caused by attempts to be 'fair' I predict this situation will continue.
- j_baker 16y agoWould it be just to subject the users of paypal to the millions of scams coming out of Nigeria for the benefit of the handful of legitimate users?
- barrkel 16y agoIf PayPal is as good at keeping your money safe as they profess, it shouldn't make a difference, right? You're making a utilitarian argument, but it seems predicated on some kind of zero sum, that the only way of protecting the world from Nigerian scams is to prevent consumers in Nigeria from being able to buy things from elsewhere. I question that assumption.