5 ms·
As much as I like "Geek wins, hah!", I would suggest not modeling this as a good practice for self-employed folks here. It is 2011: GoogLinkedBookTwitEtc have
by patio11 16y ago
As much as I like "Geek wins, hah!", I would suggest not modeling this as a good practice for self-employed folks here. It is 2011: GoogLinkedBookTwitEtc have ensured that you have exactly one professional reputation. You may think future clients will see the righteousness of your actions. Consider whether available evidence suggests that you are a good judge of the character of clients.
Come back to this post in two months if you don't buy this prediction: it is highly likely he doesn't get paid.
There are better ways to avoid nonpayment. Work with better customers - reputation works both ways. Get references if required. For projects of nontrivial length, agree to milestones and bill on successful completion. Delivery of functional code should practically always be a milestone, which would eliminate most of the downside risk here. Charge a premium, both to scare away bad clients and to cover the numerous sources of risk to your ability to pay rent, of which total refusal to pay is only one.
- alanstorm 16y agoAll true, but somehow it's comforting to know that this client and this developer deserve each other.
- bugsy 16y agoReally only a problem for clients that don't intend to pay. I believe it is a very good thing to know if the client has grave worries about what you might do if he refuses to pay. An honest client won't even be thinking of that. There's a long established legal principle that if you don't pay a workman he can place a lien on your property, which may even result in it being sold at auction. You can also be charged with theft of services, a real crime for which you go to jail. If your new client is worried he might go to jail should he be committing felonies, that is also a concern.
- robin_reala 16y agoThere's a long established legal principle that if you don't pay a workman he can place a lien on your property, which may even result in it being sold at auction. Not heard of this before - is this a US thing?
- bugsy 16y agoNo, it's not just a US thing. Various kinds of liens are part of most countries' laws, though obviously the details vary.
- Duff 16y agoIt's called a "mechanic's lien" and the scope of the liens vary from state to state and country to country.
- brc 16y agoNot sure if 'property' here is meant to mean 'real estate' or just 'property' in the sense of 'stuff you own'. While I've never heard of a house going to auction because of unpaid bills (though I'm sure it has happened), it's exceedingly common for vehicles, equipment, etc to be claimed by someone who was working on them. A very common occurence is for a mechanic to dismantle a car to find out what's wrong, then to quote the cost of repairs to be either more than the person can afford, or more than the car is worth. At that point the customer sometimes refuses to pay even the amount of work done at that point. At which point the car sits in the yard for the alloted period of time, at which point the mechanic takes ownership and sells off what is left (or, sometimes, fixes it themselves and sells for a profit). Usually the mechanic also has the right to charge a storage fee, and to levy interest on the unpaid item to increase the size of the total lien. And it's normal for the mechanic to lose out badly, which is why some people require up-front payment to undergo speculative work to find the source of a problem that could be expensive. The same goes for electronic equipment- it will cost you $200 to even open up a camera to see what is wrong, which is why most get thrown in the bin when they stop working.
- unoti 16y agopatio11 is right on the money. The linked site, and the discussions here, are testament to the fact that project management and business management are different skillsets from software development. It's not fun to make money arrangements with clients that work for both parties, but it's a vital part of running a business. For tech people, it's often neglected, because many of us just want to write code. On the bright side, it's really not that bad or uncomfortable once you become accustomed to it and have successfully navigated those waters a few times. If you are in the business of trading your time for money, then print out the last paragraph of patio11's post and meditate on it before you enter into each business arrangement.
- Confusion 16y agoYou may think future clients will see the righteousness of your action [..] And you will be wrong. When this story gets told, a future client will more readily identify with the client in the story, simply by virtue of it also being 'the client'. They will consider how this situation could come about and will come up with all kinds of reasons why someone could reasonably not want to pay you. What happens if your work sucks and you get into a serious disagreement? They would want that to be resolved via the usual ways, without them being harmed by you abusing (nb. their thoughts, it's irrelevant whether they are mine) your powers. All in all, it will mostly rub off in a bad fashion.
- doorhammer 16y agoI completely agree with this. Even if you had the legal right to remove your code, or stall the site, (I have no idea if one would. I assume it depends on contractual obligations) and even if you decided that was your only rational option, it would still be best to handle the matter tactfully. A future client, even if they agree with your motives, probably won't agree with your self-righteous customer-service methods. That's not the kind of person most people want to deal with. Maybe I'm jaded, but my opinion is that, if your job/contracts require interaction with customers, then part of your pay is to compensate for having to gracefully handle the garbage those customers throw at you. That doesn't mean you just let people abuse you, but it does mean knowing your options, and calmly taking them, or, where you really have no pragmatic recourse, washing your hands and moving on. That's why I hate ever being in a financial position where I absolutely need the current client/contract/job to survive through the next week. Just my two cents, though.