5 ms·
I have heard a few unique perspectives about Bougainville Copper. Rio Tinto held an old-fashioned and anglosphere-centric view that the government represented
by roenxi 7y ago
I have heard a few unique perspectives about Bougainville Copper.
Rio Tinto held an old-fashioned and anglosphere-centric view that the government represented the people. The idea that negotiating with a government in Port Moresby was different from negotiating with the locals; and the idea that the situation would devolve so badly were both foreign to senior management who were used to stable and representative democratic government.
Bougainville was quite a lawless place. As it turned out Rio Tinto should never have tried to invest there but it isn't obvious how they could have known that in advance. Should they not have looked to the PNG government for law enforcement? Should they have resisted the PNG military? Morally, possibly. Practically it wasn't obvious.
- qtplatypus 7y agoSure that is one factor. However the environmental impact of the mining as well as insufficient compensation to the people of Boganville is also contributed to the conflict.
- roenxi 7y ago> The mine was vitally important to the economy of Papua New Guinea. The PNG national government received a 20% share of profit from the mine, of which the Bougainvilleans received 5% - 1.25% share of the total profit [0] Present day PNG has a per-capita GDP in the single-digit thousands, and that mine was a money printing machine. Did the mine operation contribute to the conflict? Obviously yes, it was a major contributing cause. Insufficient compensation? Pull the other one, that sort profit sharing is reasonable and traditionally governments regulate if the environmental conditions aren't suitable. Besides, the environmental impact will have done them vastly less damage than them killing each other and and being dirt poor. Francis Ona did a great deal of damage to PNG and to Beugainville, as did the PNG government's obvious mismanagement of the Beugainville region. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bougainville_Copper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bougainville_Copper
- qtplatypus 7y agoFrom the wiki you are quoting from the Australian courts found that it was inadequate. As to the government environmental regulation was insufficient I completely agree. However I am of the (perhaps naive) view that a company should be engaging in best practice with regards to environmental impact rather then "Only enough to comply with local laws".
- roenxi 7y agoThat judgement is talking about a specific case of local farmers land plots damaged by building an access road; not the profit sharing situation of the mine overall. I'd be shocked if they offered something that was normal under Australian law; Australian property is worth an order of magnitude more than PNG property. Purchasing Power Parity and all that. You can't find a large project that pleases everyone. Roads, mines, skyscrapers, etc all upset somebody; such disputes are neither war crimes nor genocide. They aren't even a reflection of how much money the project is funnelling in to the local economy. Also, best practice in the 80s was pretty poor practice. Miners have learned a lot / been regulated very differently in recent decades.
- kennywinker 7y agoSo they were bumbling idiots meddling in a developing nation's politics with disastrous consequences, rather than evil 4D-chess playing corporate masterminds? Is that supposed to make me feel better about the people who died so they could get rich?
- roenxi 7y agoThere was a brutal civil war and the people of Baugainville (and PNG more broadly) lost a real albeit difficult to seize opportunity to modernise a big chunk of their country. You probably shouldn't feel better, that situation is pretty much the worst possible outcome. But to lay that at the feet of Rio Tinto and claim they were responsible for a genocide and war crimes is crazy talk. PNG as a political body wasn't organised enough to maintain order and the shock of the vast wealth (and pollution) being created at BCL was too much for their systems to handle. Rio Tinto was present, they were involved, they should have done things differently and the company changed its approach to community management afterwards. But it is a very morally ambiguous situation and the blame should probably sit with the PNG polity. It is not unreasonable for a company to expect and pressure a government to maintain law and order. Rio didn't try to set up that civil war - PNG did that to themselves. When it was obvious that the situation was getting violent Rio basically just evacuated and wrote the project off.
- kennywinker 7y ago> But to lay that at the feet of Rio Tinto and claim they were responsible for a genocide and war crimes is crazy talk. The flashpoint for the violence was the rio tinto ran mine - specifically the low wages, environmental damage, and unfair distribution of profits. To excuse them of responsibility for the ensuing violence is crazy talk. If I come to your family home, and start paying your brother to use your room as a garbage dump - am I innocent of the resulting conflict between you and your brother?
- roenxi 7y ago> If I come to your family home, and start paying your brother to use your room as a garbage dump - am I innocent of the resulting conflict between you and your brother? Yes. Obviously that is between my brother and I. Rio wanted peace and stability. If people start a civil war, that is on them. Principle of personal responsibility and all that jazz. If the Beaugainvillians (and mainlands) had behaved like civilised and reasonable people rather than reaching for explosives and violence then they would have gotten a much better outcome - that sits with them. Life is not fair, other people treating someone badly doesn't excuse their purposefully choosing poor behaviour.