4 ms·
> It distorts the entire process if no one can tell who the speech is coming from. Not if voters are rational. Rational voters will weigh everything they see a
by pdonis 7y ago
> It distorts the entire process if no one can tell who the speech is coming from.
Not if voters are rational. Rational voters will weigh everything they see and hear in terms of the track record of the source: how well has this source done at telling me the truth in the past? Obviously an unknown source--still more a source that refuses to identify itself and has no track record at all--will simply be ignored. In an environment like that, hiding the true origin of speech is self-defeating.
- mikelyons 7y agoHumans are not rational, and it's naive to believe that they ever possibly could be. Governments need to be at least as big as the corporations and the other governments they seek to regulate and defend against, otherwise things get squirrelly and dangerous.
- pdonis 7y ago> Humans are not rational, and it's naive to believe that they ever possibly could be. If this is true, we're screwed, because governments are run by humans.
- pgeorgi 7y agoGovernments have a couple of safeguards in place to deal with irrational humans running the show. Some of them are division of power and checks and balances. These safeguards are the reason why governance is sometimes slow and sometimes bulky but also why, by and large, governance doesn't fail entirely when it happens to be unjust: it can recover from most injustices (one argument against capital punishment is that there's no recovery from that). And all that is rooted in a distrust that humans do the right thing all the time - without that assumption you wouldn't need these mechanisms with all their overhead, you'd just appoint a philosopher king. [edit to add: One problem is when some of these powers aren't doing their job. Checks and balances break down when (for example) the legislature devolves into playing the executive's yes-men instead of directing its activities.]
- pdonis 7y agoAll of these safeguards depend on people being rational--at least rational enough to watch whether the safeguards are working. If people aren't willing to do that, the safeguards break down. For example: the US Congress has something like a 98% re-election rate for incumbents and an approval rating in the single digits. That means important safeguards are not working.
- someguydave 7y agoDoes that mean democracy is unsafe?
- pdonis 7y agoIt means a democracy in which voters are unwilling or unable to hold elected representatives accountable for maintaining the safeguards is unsafe.
- someguydave 7y agoFair enough - we need to limit the vote to the responsible voters only - for the safety of the people.
- mikelyons 7y agoNo. We need an educated populous, and not just educated in rationality but in spirituality as well. Not religious dogmatic mechanistic ritualism corrupted for selfish motives, but open one-with-all selfless spirituality that seeks to promote future generations instead of stealing from them for the goals of the ego.
- abathur 7y agoI don't really think it's all that useful to think of even individual humans as rational or irrational, but in any case: Governments (much like cities, markets, neighborhoods, societies, companies, social networks, "the media", political parties, academia, unions, religions, etc.) are "run by humans" somewhat like flocks are run by birds. Yes, studying the nature of individual birds can teach you a little bit about flocks, but you've zoomed out to a level where it's more useful to talk about systems and dynamics. Can't see the forest for the trees, as they say.
- pdonis 7y agoThis amounts to saying: we humans can't really predict the behavior of entities like governments. That just makes the problem I was pointing at worse.
- abathur 7y agoNo, it doesn't. It amounts to saying that different rules and dynamics govern higher-order systems. It's not that the ir-/rationality of individual participants isn't a factor--but multiple interacting systems and feedback loops are creating the weather that those actors have to make decisions within.
- abathur 7y agoThis doesn't scale. Even investors and economic agents can't be said to behave this way, and their incentives to put in the effort are much more immediate and explicit. Few people have the time, resources, patience, persistence, and expertise even figure out whether any single thing a single source said is true. (Imagine someone makes a single claim backed by a mountain of "true" data, but ignores some problematic data. Time, a little domain knowledge, and patience might suffice to validate the ground-level truth of what they did cite, but I'm not sure anything short of domain expertise will be able to view it in light of everything it didn't cite.)
- pdonis 7y ago> Few people have the time, resources, patience, persistence, and expertise even figure out whether any single thing a single source said is true. First, the amount of effort you invest should be proportional to the extent to which you care about whether the thing is true. If you care a lot, you should invest a lot of resources. If you don't care much, you shouldn't invest much. If you don't care at all, you should not invest any resources and you shouldn't have an opinion at all. Second, for most things where you actually need to know what's true in order to live your everyday life, you can test things by direct experience. And for most things that you can't test by direct experience, you don't actually care about what's true; expressions of opinion one way or the other are signaling, not actual commitments to the truth of the opinion expressed. This is easy to see because most people don't actually govern their actions according to, for example, the political opinions they express. And third, the only alternative solution to figuring it out for yourself is finding some third party that you can trust to do the work for you and truthfully convey to you the results. But then you have to decide which third parties to trust, and that just puts you right back at the same problem: few people have the time, patience, persistence, and expertise to actually evaluate the track record of truthfulness and accuracy of third parties. And every shortcut to that process can be, will be, and has been gamed.
- groby_b 7y agoSure. But voters aren't rational. We've just gone through that with economics - the homo economicus is bull - and I suppose we need to repeat that for the ultrarational libertarian crowd. This is not how this works. This is not how any of it works. Humans are vulnerable to emotions. To lies they want to believe. To subtle influence just outside their daily cognition. To cheap dopamine hits from cheesy entertainment. Believing that rational voters and some sort of speech attribution system will help solve all ills is beyond naive.
- pdonis 7y ago> voters aren't rational And if that's the case, we're screwed, because no system of government can produce good government if the people don't know it when they see it and aren't willing to vote for it or against the lack of it.
- groby_b 7y agoEducation is a semi-decent counter. So is complete deplatforming of people attempting to radicalize other people. But yes, unrestrained capitalism + unrestrained privatization + unrestrained speech + democracy is not a combination that sustainably works, the way it looks.
- someguydave 7y agoMore importantly, voters need to have skin in the game. If they can vote themselves unlimited benefits without themselves being personally liable for the costs, then republic will fall. My solution: you only get to vote if you paid net tax for the year, less wealth transfer payments.