5 ms·
Humans.txt, like robots.txt, but for humans.
- panic 16y agoWhat is it? An initiative to know the creators of the website. A TXT file that contains the information about the different people who have contributed to the web building. Robots.txt specifies a set of URLs that automated crawlers are not supposed to access. I'm not sure how this is "like robots.txt, but for humans".
- w1ntermute 16y agoThey just used the name because it sounds catchy/linkbaity.
- Zev 16y agoMy guess is that the theory behind this is - Robots.txt : File that robots look for, to get certain kinds of information about a site :: Humans.txt : File that people look for, certain kinds of to get information about a site.
- corin_ 16y agoWhy does http://humanstxt.org/H-team.php http://humanstxt.org/H-team.php exist, surely they should just link straight to http://humanstxt.org/humans.txt http://humanstxt.org/humans.txt! Anyway, pointless initiative. Can't help but think that this feels like a project you create in the hope of getting attention from people saying writing blogs about them trying to start something new, not in the hope of it actually taking off. I mean, robots.txt makes sense because robots know to look for it. It obviously makes 100x more sense to have a hyperlink to an "about us" or "who's behind this site?" page with a URL of their choice, if it's designed for people to read. Oh, and many, many sites already do that.
- Vivtek 16y agoI think this is an attempt to create a soopersekrit easter egg standard so that the guys who write a site can pat each other on the back without the customer needing to know about it.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yeahsure 16y agoI like the idea of giving the developers/designers/copywrites/whatever some credit, however, I doubt this is the way it should be done. Most web designers/developers/agencies already place a link in the website's footer so it's not that hard to know who was involved.
- Emore 16y agoHow many people does it take to put up a website promoting a txt-file addition to webroot? 5, apparently. Next up they'll take millions in VC, integrate with Facebook and write blog posts on it all. </sarcasm> Somehow a balance should be kept between technology involved and ego show-off: Static webpage: barely qualifies for even any credit. Contains sign-up form: a minimal "About" page. Asks for personal info: names and credible external links. Charges you money: add photos of yourselves and references. Etcetera.
- reitzensteinm 16y agoThat was my first thought, but apparently it's seven! http://humanstxt.org/humans.txt http://humanstxt.org/humans.txt No wonder they're looking for a standard way to structure author information - they're generating so much of it that it'll soon become unweildy.
- alnayyir 16y agoWinter must be very slow in Spain.
- coderdude 16y agoThere is something like this for advertising the contact information for a site. It's called info.txt. http://www.aota.net/forums/archive/index.php/t-18373.html http://www.aota.net/forums/archive/index.php/t-18373.html It looks like this (erroneously named robots.txt by this site owner): http://www.melodilerim.com/robots.txt http://www.melodilerim.com/robots.txt
- randrews 16y agoI like this, but I think that any site that implements it will have the same result Netscape did: http://www.jwz.org/doc/about.html http://www.jwz.org/doc/about.html
- jpadvo 16y agoIt sounds like the "bickering" at Netscape over their about:authors page was simply the result of having a culture where people would bicker about things like the details of an about:authors page.
- LordLandon 16y agoOh, are we trying to make it easier for spambots to harvest our email addresses now?
- jrockway 16y agoSpambots already have your email address. Get a filter.
- wyclif 16y agoI'd rather not speculate as to the usefulness of this, but I do know one thing: the English here is off and needs to be cleaned up (I realise the authors are Spanish).
- tuhin 16y ago"like robots.txt, but for humans" This is indeed nothing but a marketing/PR gimmick. The only connotation that I could think of was that like Robots.txt has to do something with robots, this has something to do with Humans. Utility: I won't go on to say it is completely useless. While many sites have an about or colophon section, they end up naming people who are most active or at the top of the ladder. What about facebook with so many employees? That is where I see this essentially being used. As I tweeted, it is more like the Credits section for the web.
- noibl 16y agoThe idea of hard coding a URI, like is done for robots.txt is a bad idea. Let's not continue to make the same mistakes over and over again. -- http://bitworking.org/news/No_Fishing http://bitworking.org/news/No_Fishing Fair comment here[1] about the specific case of robots.txt, but lets not do this kind of thing gratuitously. Maybe what we need instead is the X-BOFH header[2]: X-BOFH: http://www.xxxxx.de/bofh/xxxxxx.html The actual URL it points to has been obscured to protect the guilty, and a local mirror[3] provided in its stead. [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=639337 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=639337 [2] http://www.nextthing.org/archives/2005/08/07/fun-with-http-headers http://www.nextthing.org/archives/2005/08/07/fun-with-http-h... [3] http://www.nextthing.org/blog/cache/bofh_edited.html http://www.nextthing.org/blog/cache/bofh_edited.html
- hippich 16y agoFor some reason I believe if this will take off it will be used by robots not humans..
- SapphireSun 16y agoFor instance, to mine who the creators of websites are for employment websites and search.
- lostbit 16y agoAgreed. After some time there would be a database and a ranking with web site authors, skills, languages, etc. Interested people would look into it to find people that match their type of site design...
- jrockway 16y agoThis is probably the dumbest thing I've ever seen on HN. I'm going to flag it and pretend that this was just a very bad dream.
- thetylerhayes 16y agoAll the comments and suggestions here are good. One more: why not just use the meta tags for this same purpose? Then you don't even need to create another file. There's already an 'author' meta name attribute for instance, and you can define your own on-the-fly too.
- bl4k 16y agorobots.txt is meant to be read by robots, hence the markup and location. for humans just use normal web pages. like an 'about' page, for example
- qntm 16y agoPerhaps humans.txt would suggest which kinds of humans should and should not visit this site. Under-18s, for example.
- Mithrandir 16y agoIt's about the developers, not the users.
- qntm 16y agoI know what it is about. I'm suggesting a humans.txt which actually makes a decent analogy with robots.txt.
- jpadvo 16y agoI'm kind of surprised at all the grumpy comments -- this idea made me smile. I like the idea of a team leaving their collective signature in a hidden-away corner of a website. The semi-secrecy (after all, how many people are ever going to read a websites humans.txt?) and feeling of ownership that this gives is really neat. My projects are getting a humans.txt!
- whyworryagain 16y agoOne major flaw of this approach is that people who currently have control of the site will edit out the people who worked on the site before. The only way to do it fool-proof is to use a service like http://creatorfinder.com http://creatorfinder.com they store a history of creators and also allow all your verified portfolio for a creator to be displayed.
- mmaunder 16y agoOh god.
- Ruudjah 16y agoHorrible idea. You move the "about" page to some monospace non-marked up page. This just creates an excuse not to make a dcent "about"page.
- j05h 16y agoWhen doing contract work, you don't normally get credit for a site on the about page. Sometimes you may get permission to add a footer link. I think this is great for those situations where you don't get either. My hope would be that most companies would not mind a simple text file in the root which isn't linked anywhere but is well-known. My portfolio of sites becomes verifiable. Yes, I built these sites, and here are the humans.txt files to prove it. I've been at plenty of companies and built many sites and can't really prove I had hand in putting building any of them.
- limmeau 16y agoYou could encode a fingerprint of a signing key in a comment tag and offer to sign doubtful peoples' nonces with that key.
- mryall 16y agoYou could just use a meta tag or link tag with rel="author". Both are hidden from users and, unlike this proposal, are also de facto standards for including author information in web pages.
- nhebb 16y agoWhat if I dream electric sheep? Do I add androids.txt?
- iamdave 16y ago+10 Phillip K Dick points to you, sir
- richbradshaw 16y agoI see this being useful for future developers – the number of sites I've taken over with no idea who made it or how to get server access etc. Having an easy way to find out how to contact would make things much better than having to wget everything each time.
- mrspeaker 16y agoI thought these guys had ripped off my revolutionary idea "humans.txt": http://www.mrspeaker.net/2010/07/15/humans-txt/ http://www.mrspeaker.net/2010/07/15/humans-txt/ But it turns out they were trying to do something useful, not devise a system for preventing pesky humans from wasting precious robot bandwidth. I think I like my idea better though.
- adulau 16y agoFrom their humans.txt file, Chef:Juanjo Bernabeu I don't understand the key value format used if this is for human. It would have been more appropriate to use a format like "The Chef is" if this is for a human-being. Or is the file to be read by robots to treat better human? In other words, I don't know if this initiative will really help us to preserve the three laws of robotics - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Laws_of_Robotics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Laws_of_Robotics .
- rahoulb 16y ago(Slightly tangential but) I like this: http://www.thinkvisibility.com/robots.txt http://www.thinkvisibility.com/robots.txt
- realdealrep 16y agowhy you copy what @smashingmagazine tweet??? twitter stealer!!
- jawee 16y agoDidn´t something like this used to be achieved with meta tags anyway? I remember when it was common to have meta tags with author names, editors (I have often seem the generator often used on many WYSIWYG editors assigned to the author´s text editor), and contact information.
- there 16y agoi love the irony in reading "We Are People, Not Machines." just as the font-face css loaded and converted the entire page from a human-readable variable-width font to a machine-like fixed-width font.
- Legion 16y agoAs many have pointed out, this is not really analogous to robots.txt. The first thing I imagined was a text file that said stuff like, "Don't read anything in the Features section. Also, don't try to use the admin login panel!" But really, what this idea should be called is developers.txt. I thought it was a silly idea, until someone else here talked about it providing a way of verifying work. Anyone can post a website with screen captures of other sites, and claim they worked on them. Even if the site does list a developer firm in the footer, as long as I worked there, I can claim to have worked on that site. A developers.txt file like their example would make for a verifiable list of the people who actually worked on the site, in a way that does not add clutter to the actual content. I know clients we work with probably don't want us putting all our names on their About page, but would have no problems with a developers.txt file that normal users are never going to see.