3 ms·
> I’m pleasantly surprised to hear Zuckerberg articulate this thought. I'm pleasantly surprised that people are waking up to this problem, but disappointed as
by vkou 7y ago
> I’m pleasantly surprised to hear Zuckerberg articulate this thought.
I'm pleasantly surprised that people are waking up to this problem, but disappointed as hell that what they are waking up to is not the problem - but rather, the disruption of the status quo.
To the rest of the world, American values, media, culture, etc, being the dominant shaping force on the internet (And before that, through literature, television, film, etc) was cultural imperialism, that has shifted discourse, starved local culture, and, in short, was Americanizing the world. [1]
Americans now feel threatened by China's cultural weight being thrown around in this space. Okay. You don't like China using the same mechanisms that you used in the past, to broadcast and spread your mono-culture.
But instead of taking a moment to self-reflect, about whether it is good for the world to have an 800-pound cultural gorilla warping discourse, culture, and media around the world...
... We are upset that we stopped being that gorilla! It's more than a little hypocritical and peevish.
[1] Talk to a Canadian sometime, and ask them about Canadian culture, versus American culture - in the media sense. You'll find there to be very little of the former left, despite the government's best efforts to promote, and develop it.
- ivl 7y agoThe difference is that with American cultural values the freedom to criticize them remains. The option exists to say "I don't care for the US's culture or values". I fear the concept of an internet where posts are censored and police arrive at your door for the wrong opinion.
- vkou 7y agoThe option also exists to say "I don't care for China's culture of values", you just have to not worry about selling your media there. You're speaking from an incredible position of privilege - from the point of view of a net exporter of culture. Countries that were net importers of culture never had this concern. Nobody in Germany would care about this sort of thing, for instance, because, I am sorry to say, nobody outside of Germany consumes German culture. Nobody in Germany needs to tailor their speech to not offend China, because nobody in China cares to listen to what they, their films, or their sports teams have to say. This whole thing is uniquely an American problem - and you're discovering what it feels like to have your culture be shaped by the orthodoxies of a foreign set of values. It sucks, but that's how the rest of the world has had to operate for a long, long time.
- harryh 7y agonobody outside of Germany consumes German culture Everyone in the world that listens to electronic music would like to disagree with you.
- rayiner 7y agoIt's not just America's problem, it's everyone's problem. It's a problem for people in the developing world who will be dominated by Chinese and other influences. I'm from Bangladesh, where we have some high-minded, western ideas of freedom of speech and press baked into our constitution. It's a good start, but our implementation has been less than perfect to date: https://www.dw.com/en/is-bangladeshs-media-freedom-deteriorating/a-44854327 https://www.dw.com/en/is-bangladeshs-media-freedom-deteriora.... I had long assumed--hoped--that the arc of history would point in only one way: closing the gap between practice and ideal in the direction of more freedom. But what now? Bangladesh is beset by forces that don't value liberty. Wahhabism from one side and Chinese Communism from the other. Neither is the path to enduring liberty and prosperity for Bangladeshis. Who will fight those forces? Europe long ago abdicated any role in evangelizing its own ideas. Americans are the only westerners left who believe in their hearts that their values are universal, and that means the world need America more than ever. The last thing they need is for America to equivocate, pull back, or, worse, start dismantling its own framework of liberty.
- pesmhey 7y agoto broadcast and spread your mono-culture. America is, and has been, the polar opposite of a monoculture.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]