4 ms·
> but does commingling mean they can't trace it back to which seller sent it to them for FBA? If they can, they can penalize that seller... Correct, they can't
by crazygringo 7y ago
> but does commingling mean they can't trace it back to which seller sent it to them for FBA? If they can, they can penalize that seller...
Correct, they can't trace it, so they can't penalize.
> I'm assuming Amazon has a unique id for every individual item in their warehouses.
They don't. If they did, there would be some kind of unique bar code on every item you received from Amazon.
- QuotedForTruth 7y agoCommingling (in this context) doesn't necessarily mean that the products are literally sitting in the same bin as the same product from another seller. Each seller's items could be kept in separate bins if put in the same warehouse. Then when one of that product is ordered, the picker is told to go to a specific bin to get it. Amazon would then still know which seller's product they sold you. The actual advantage of commingling comes from the fact that amazon doesn't have to distribute every sellers items across the US. They can just send you one from the closest warehouse.
- FireBeyond 7y agoThat takes up more warehouse space, which is what Amazon is trying to avoid. Much easier to put it all into one big bin, and if you want, they can charge you to have your own bin.
- adrianmonk 7y agoSeems easy enough to work around. Just fill the extra space with completely different products. Put the other seller's products in a different location, also mixed in with other stuff. The rule would be that you can put two products together if they are either the same seller (in which case you don't need to distinguish) or a different product (in which case you can distinguish visually). Amazon already mixes different products in the same slot in order to optimize space anyway.
- hinkley 7y agoYeah I'm struggling with the notion of why commingling prevents audit trails. You don't even have to use separate bins for audits, although I admit that makes it pretty trivial. You just need a label.
- AnssiH 7y agoThe FAQ on seller help pages (at least in Europe) specifically says that they track commingled inventory by having their warehouse storage logic assign units from different sellers always into separate bins. This article has comments from Amazon US spokesman who confirms it is the same over there: https://outline.com/4R7fp6 https://outline.com/4R7fp6
- adrianmonk 7y agoA unique barcode on the item would be one way to do it, but not the only way. For example, a common thing to do on conveyors is to have reusable open-top plastic bins called "totes". (Think of going through airport security where you stick your luggage items into a plastic tray or tub that sits on the conveyor as it goes through the x-ray machine.) The totes can have barcodes on them, which can be used to track whatever is inside the tote. Amazon could use a system like that to individually track items as they're being moved on and off shelves. And while on the shelves, it could track items by position (a database saying this particular item is on that position of that shelf). By combining these two things, they could track the position of individual items without sticking barcodes on them. I don't know whether Amazon actually does this. I'm just saying it's not impossible.
- ikeboy 7y agoThis is incorrect. https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/external/200141480 https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/external/200141480 explicitly stated that they track which seller it comes from. They don't need to label each product, they just need to know which location it came from and store different sellers products in different locations, which they do.