5 ms·
You just described most of the Midwest. That geographic structure is just the product of the large agricultural sector. But on many objective measures (home own
by rayiner 7y ago
You just described most of the Midwest. That geographic structure is just the product of the large agricultural sector. But on many objective measures (home ownership rates, homelessness rates, poverty rates, median purchasing power, school quality, homicide rates), Iowa, Nebraska, Idaho, Minnesota, etc., significantly outperform California or New York.
Bleak is a relative term. I’d call it “bleak” if young people have to leave the place where they grew up just to be able to afford a house in a decent school district. Where people are tied together by little more than what industry they work in or maybe the fancy gym they go to.
- dmode 7y agoHow can you compare states with little population to a state with 40 mn people ? Of course numbers will look better in a smallish state. Also, how do these states perform when it comes to healthcare access, LGBT rights, environmental changes, renewable energy, immigrant rights ? School quality ? Comparing mostly white states with a state that has 50% 1st or 2nd generation migrants, with non native English speaking parents ? Homicide rates ? SF is on track to have the lowest homicide rate in 50 years. On average, California performs far better than any of the states you mentioned and that is proven by the population differences
- rayiner 7y ago> How can you compare states with little population to a state with 40 mn people ? Of course numbers will look better in a smallish state. These are percentage rates, not absolute numbers, so it's not obvious why the numbers will look better in a smaller state. > On average, California performs far better than any of the states you mentioned and that is proven by the population differences California performs worse on many metrics even accounting for demographic differences. For example, in Iowa, Hispanic children score an average of 273 in NAEP's 8th grade math test. In California, they score just 262. In Texas it's 274. Median income for hispanic-headed households in California is about $46,000, versus $48,000 in Iowa. (Adjusted for cost of living, Hispanic households in Iowa have 30% more purchasing power than Hispanic households in California.)
- notfromhere 7y agoThe Midwest is a lot more diverse than people realize - this comment just betrays a lack of knowledge. The Midwest is a lot more than Iowa cornfields and American flags.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAnd even Iowa Cornfields are host to some LGBT-friendly communities.