5 ms·
Seems they would be a decent candidate to try out UBI and see if in practice it works. They’ve got wealth and they have lots of underemployed and unemployed.
by mc32 7y ago
Seems they would be a decent candidate to try out UBI and see if in practice it works.
They’ve got wealth and they have lots of underemployed and unemployed.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ilamont 7y agoThey already do have a benefits system in place that includes cash payouts to low and middle income families, plus bonuses for state employees (70% of Saudi nationals), stipends for students, tax breaks on home purchases, etc.
- mc32 7y agoIs it set up as a UBI and is it proving itself, will it remain sustainable?
- ilamont 7y agoHonest question: Does it matter? The current iteration is called the Citizen's Account program. But if it were called Saudi Basic Income, Saudi Social Security, or Saudi Protection Net, wouldn't the net impact be the same -- a scaled system of cash payouts for low and middle income citizens to support basic living expenses?
- LegitShady 7y agoIt matters so much.
- w457uiw4gftyi 7y agoThe name might not matter but the post you responded to asked if it was set up as a Universal Basic Income, which does matter. One of the claims UBI-backers make is the fact that giving everyone the same amount of money will be much simpler and require much less bureaucracy than income-based welfare schemes. So, I get my $1k this month, you get your $1k, the homeless guy under the bridge gets his $1k, Bill Gates gets his $1k, etc.
- lmm 7y agoA reliable income that you're entitled to might lead to very different behaviour than a contingent programme.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 7y agoDo you mean having the regime throw as few crumbs as necessary to the population just to avoid a dictatorship overthrow? Perhaps what people need is not money but the political power to decide what they want to do with their common wealth (which could be UBI, of course).
- mc32 7y agoMaybe but I can see how it could actually end up in “give it all to us right now” which obviously would short circuit the whole idea.
- psv1 7y agoSeems like the worst candidate to see if UBI works in practice - due to the very specific political, cultural and economic climate in Saudi Arabia, UBI failing or working well won't be any indicator whatsoever about UBI's viability in another country.
- tigershark 7y agoIt seems scarily close to the justifications sought for communism/socialism. The usual excuse is that it didn’t work because it was not implemented correctly in Russia, North Korea, China, Cuba, Venezuela... etc. etc.
- psv1 7y ago> UBI failing or working well won't be any indicator I haven't commented on UBI itself at all. I'm simply pointing out that lessons learned in Saudi Arabia hardly carry over anywhere else. Not sure which part is scary.
- tigershark 7y agoYou are saying that if UBI fails in Saudi Arabia you can’t extrapolate the failure in any other country. And it’s exactly the same thing that people say to defend communism. They assert that communism failed because: “Russia seems like the worst candidate to see if communism works in practice - due to the very specific political, cultural and economic climate in Russia, communism failing or working well won't be any indicator whatsoever about communism's viability in another country.”
- wayoutthere 7y agoI'm as lefty-socialist as they come, but we have to be careful because UBI schemes can also look like the UAE -- which has created an upper class of "citizens" who receive a generous stipend and an undocumented underclass of people with no rights. Stateless refugees are a big problem today, and climate change is going to create a lot more of them. Jewish people were the group left stateless in the nationalist period after WWI, and we all know what happened there. If no country is willing to protect the rights of people whose nations deem them "problematic", UBI won't matter because there is still going to be an underclass that doesn't officially have rights and can be persecuted. You can then just cram all your political opponents into that box and watch fascism happen.
- LegitShady 7y agoUBI is nonsense socialism campaigning for the votes of the uninformed "We'll just give everyone money. Nobody will demand more and the promise of more money won't become the key election issue as governments directly try to buy off their citizens for votes. Nothing can go wrong." Huh why would you do that! "AI!" It's like a comedy but it's not actually funny, just full of clowns.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoWhile the tone of your post is a little rough, I am curious to see if any of the readers here agree that UBI isn't a great idea for our current society I for one don't understand how it won't cause mass inflation. Every reason I read for why it won't is usually along the lines of "we did an experiment with 100 people, it turned out great!" 100 people != the population of a country
- navigatesol 7y ago>I for one don't understand how it won't cause mass inflation. America already gives away vast sums of money to various people and programs, over $2 trillion annually. UBI is just a way of saying, "here's your share, spend it how you wish".
- LegitShady 7y agoAnd then people will vote in parties whose position is ever increasing of the dole and it's a swift race for he socialist bottom. A pipe dream that doesn't actually reflect human behaviour just the inclinations of some to demand others' things while calling them greedy.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoFrom what I understand it, UBI (as proposed by Andrew Yang) will give a lot who are not receiving any money whatsoever (from any government programs) income they didn't necessarily need. aka, he is proposing to give both impoverished people and billionaires UBI
- 7y ago