3 ms·
Is it though? Is it ad hominem to identify and separate people who know something about a thing from those who don’t?
by willis936 7y ago
Is it though? Is it ad hominem to identify and separate people who know something about a thing from those who don’t?
- notacoward 7y agoYou raise a good point. When an appeal to authority has already made credentials etc. the issue, challenging that appeal becomes valid. The problem is that OP wasn't just an appeal to authority. It did not open that door. It did make arguments other than identity, and linked to fuller expositions of those arguments. Thus, addressing only identity and ignoring any arguments in either direction remains ad hominem.