2 ms·
That seems like a strange workaround. Wouldn't the burden of proof to subpoena to Amazon be the same as a warrant to the user?
by ineedasername 7y ago
That seems like a strange workaround. Wouldn't the burden of proof to subpoena to Amazon be the same as a warrant to the user?
- koolba 7y agoAmazon owns the video, not the user, so you only need a warrant if they demand one. They’re also free to not require one.
- ineedasername 7y agoThat makes sense, although it's not a subpoena in that case. It's just Amazon voluntarily cooperating. However, I'm not a fan of such voluntary cooperation. I think a company's default response should be, "We'll help you in every way possible once there is a warrant." I mean, something like this should be viewed in the context of comparable IRL vendors. If I rent a 3rd-party storage unit from U-Haul or similar, a warrant is generally required. (one exception I found was a case where police, on-site, witnessed a drug deal. They then used the defendant's key to open their unit without a warrant. It was judged lawful, that finding drugs and keycard on the defendant was sufficient probably cause. That makes sense, given that if police witness you in front of your house, or car, etc selling drugs, that would be sufficient as well to search.) [0] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ilnd-1_14-cr-00696/pdf/USCOURTS-ilnd-1_14-cr-00696-0.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ilnd-1_14-cr-00...
- greenyoda 7y agoThis isn't an actual subpoena - a subpoena is an order issued by a court, and requires probable cause. What's happening here is that the cops are asking Amazon for the data, and Amazon is giving it to them, without being legally obligated to do so. Assuming that the user's terms of service say that Amazon can do this, they don't need your permission to do so, or any proof that a crime has occurred. I assume it's legal for Amazon to give them these videos, since the images they're asking for are things that the cops or anyone else could have seen happening outside your house if they would have been driving by (or that your neighbors could have told the cops). There's no legal expectation of privacy, as there would be inside your house.