7 ms·
A dark pattern implies something that is intentionally misleading. This is just lying. This is not a dark pattern because it’s Worse.
by jchw 7y ago
A dark pattern implies something that is intentionally misleading. This is just lying. This is not a dark pattern because it’s Worse.
- OrgNet 7y agoLying, just like "parallel construction".
- buboard 7y agoI mean, you can't be sure they're lying. Odds are nonzero that 38 ppl were looking at that flight
- tmh88j 7y ago>I mean, you can't be sure they're lying. Odds are nonzero that 38 ppl were looking at that flight I suggest you click on the link, they absolutely are lying. They're using JS to generate a random number between 28 and 45. If there happens to be 38 people looking at that flight it's entirely coincidental.
- vgaldikas 7y agoYou don't do sarcasm, do you
- runarberg 7y agoIt is lying. They claim something that they have no evidence for. Whether the number truly is 38 at that moment is irrelevant in this case. Because if the number was 0, 42, or 1437 they still would have made the claim that 38 were looking at that flight.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoIn any negotiation, nobody should take (at face value) the reported interest of the other party. A real estate agent could say a dozen people dropped by the home earlier today. You'd be foolish to believe it. You'd be foolish to believe Booking.com saying there's 1 room left, or the number of people currently looking at a webpage.
- ARandomerDude 7y agoWhy shift the blame to the victim? Is "you shouldn't lie" really so controversial?
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoIt isn't controversial. But we should teach people to think independently, rather than devaluing education and critical thinking. Why not have both? Businesses should have integrity and consumers should be able to apply a basic level of critical thinking. I don't think I placed blame on the victim, either. I'm merely pointing out people should think critically of what they read, because that has a lot of valuable applications in life, beyond outside of protecting yourself from people who will lie to you.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI think we should also teach people some epistemological self-defense. People caught on lying should be punished, hard. Lying to others is an inherently hostile act.
- colejohnson66 7y agoDeceptive advertising is already under the FTC’s purview
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThat's good, but I'm talking about lying outside of deceptive advertising. There's plenty of lying going on in sales&marketing that doesn't reach the level of being illegal. Puffery comes to mind.
- jchw 7y agoSure, randomly picking a number is bound to land on the right answer eventually, but the website is still lying because it is telling you 38 even though it doesn’t actually know that. It is assuring you something that it provably doesn’t know. That’s a lie, correct or incorrect.
- anonytrary 7y agoLying is also intentionally misleading, so I'm not sure if your conclusion makes sense. Plus I would assume recurrent lying falls under the "dark pattern" category -- it certainly isn't a good or neutral pattern.
- jchw 7y agoWe don’t need another word for lying. Dark patterns are trying to trick your users into doing something they didn’t want to. The term exists because other terms didn’t capture this undesirable behavior well enough, and it need not be expanded to literally anything negative. And not all sales/marketing tricks are inherently evil. I don’t think eBay telling you how many users watched an item in the past hour is immoral so as long as it’s accurate.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoDisagree. "Dark patterns" exist because enough people talking about them are also working in or tangential to marketing, which makes them uncomfortable calling it what it is - lying, abuse, dishonesty, malicious activity, exploiting people. "Dark patters" is just an euphemism.
- jchw 7y agoThat doesn't sound at all like the history of the term dark pattern. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_pattern https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_pattern
- kbenson 7y agoLying is stating something untrue as true. A dark pattern works on implicit assumptions to get people to believe something without having to state it. Lying is fraud, plain and simple, the laws and courts nailed that hundreds of years ago. A dark patter may be fraud, or in some way illegal, or may not, depending on details and jurisdiction. Those details might also include intent. An accidentally bad UI that costs customers money is not the same as a UI that purposefully leads customers to the same situation depending on what you're trying to determine (i.e. was the law broken, or is the UI not good).
- zimbatm 7y agoMaybe they know that statistically, based on their historical traffic, there are between 28 and 45 people visiting the page. Calling 28 + rand(45 - 28) is certainly much more efficient than fetching the data on the fly. That would be the most charitable interpretation.