5 ms·
Who is starting large-scale new projects in Java in 2019?
by TylerE 7y ago
Who is starting large-scale new projects in Java in 2019?
- victor106 7y agoOne of my clients handles 90% of all the pbm routing in the US, which is millions of transactions per second. They started to completely modernize the application on java... primarily Spring Boot and Apache Geode. After some optimizations they are very happy with the performance and expressiveness of modern java.
- TylerE 7y agoI said new projects. Not upgrades.
- GordonS 7y agoNot the OP, but I understood their comment to mean 'a rewrite in Java of a legacy system written in some other language'?
- victor106 7y agoExactly right. Java has lots to improve on but there seems to be unsubstantiated hate towards Java on HN which I find contrary to what happens in the real world. In the real world companies find hiring Java programmers relatively easy (maybe not the best and brightest) who can get a project off the ground easily
- pjmlp 7y agoPlenty of companies free of magpie developers.
- TylerE 7y agoI asked for examples, not platitudes.
- pjmlp 7y agoPick random names out of Fortune 500 companies. Java projects get done all the time. Additionally, even though it isn't standard Java, I have plenty of new apps running on my pocket.
- SEJeff 7y agoTwitter, and they write some really good open source stuff too. If you're writing rpc services in java I'd almost argue you should default to considering Finagle: https://twitter.github.io/finagle/ https://twitter.github.io/finagle/
- coldtea 7y agoAnd yet you only offered a misinformed platitude in the form of a question. Google does all kind of new Java work (Golang contrary to myth, is just one of the languages Google uses for internal stuff, and niche at that), Amazon of course, most of Apple's backend services are Java, Twitter, AirBnB, Uber, LinkedIn, TripAdvisor, and tons of others use Java, and write green stuff in it all the time...
- Thaxll 7y agoUber back end is mostly Go.
- jedberg 7y agoA big chuck of Netflix is written in Java, and they make new stuff in Java all the time.
- hsaliak 7y agoGoogle
- coldtea 7y agoCountless companies, huge and small -- from Apple and Amazon, to Google and your friendly local startup, plus all the enterprise world that's not a .NET shop... In what parallel universe is not Java immensely popular or not used for green projects?
- dunefox 7y agoHopefully in every universe where Kotlin exists.
- lostcolony 7y agoI can think of at least one universe where Kotlin exists, but most new JVM development is still in Java.
- cutler 7y agoKotlin != Java .... unfortunately. Sorry Jetbrains.
- pjmlp 7y agoKotlin is meaningless without Java. It is a fools errand to think Kotlin/Native would ever overtake Java. Only on Android it might have a future, if Fuchsia never becomes a thing.
- watt 7y agoKotlin might become the default Java syntax, that's what the GP is saying. And I agree.
- pjmlp 7y agoJava is Java. On what concerns the JVM, Kotlin hype will be over in a couple of years, and it will get as much use as Scala, Clojure, Beanshell, Groovy enjoy nowadays. Guest languages never get to own a platform, and with time all platform languages end up getting enough features that the large majority of developers never bother with extra tooling, debugging layer and idiomatic wrapper libraries of the guest languages.
- lucidone 7y agoI write JavaScript all day and wish I could write in Java.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoFor large scale projects, Java and C++ remain the go-to languages. I've seen a little bit of Go start to show up but no others. Other languages are used for libraries (Rust, C), only at certain employers (OCaml, Erlang), or for small-scale projects (nearly everything else).
- rswail 7y agoOn C++, inertia is a wonderful thing. Java has the benefits of extensive dependency injection and JVM/ecosystem tools that lower the risk of deployment of code. .NET also provides the controlled "managed code" environment of CLR. Why any enterprise would use C++ for standard "business" or "large scale" programming makes no sense to me. Enterprises want stability, not speed to market. Most of their infrastructure changes slowly (as in features deployed once or twice a year maybe). They have stable support mechanisms for this, including long and complex processes of approval.
- pjmlp 7y agoAs ex-C++ dev, that lives in the Java/.NET worlds since 2005, because they still don't cover all use cases where C++ might be needed. So while you might not write it as full stack C++, a couple of native libraries might be required as dependency, to access OS features, give some help to the AOT/JIT compilers, or in Java's case implementation of more machine friendly data structures.
- typon 7y agoIt's a good question. Why would you pick Java over Go or C++?
- flukus 7y agoC++ is mostly in a different but overlapping use case these days, used for system software or where performance is critical. Go is still a niche language most developers haven't heard of and with no readily available for hire talent pool. I'm not a fan of the language, but java has a huge number of developers, a rich mature ecosystem of software and is quite productive (enterprise patterns aside), it's a good sweet spot for most companies.
- WatchDog 7y agoWhy would you pick Go or C++ over Java? C++ is a hydra of complexity, sure it has it's place, but it's not nearly as productive as Java for your typical web application. Go is almost the opposite, so simple it lacks features like generics. The last time I used Go it had fundamental usability issues around dependency management(although I think recent versions have improved on vendoring a little).
- adev_ 7y ago> C++ is a hydra of complexity, sure it has it's place, but it's not nearly as productive as Java for your typical web application. Modern C++ well is as productive ( probably even more productive ) as Java. The main issue with C++ is recruitment, C++ engineers are rare because C++ is barely teached.
- rswail 7y agoC++ is barely taught in ProgrammerGenerationFactories because "modern" C++ still allows "old" C++ and makes it difficult to stop developers from doing that. Just like MISRA tries to constrain C programmers from doing dumb things in the embedded world, "modern" C++ tries to the same in the business world. But there isn't an easy way to enforce it, especially when you're outsourcing to some code sweatshop.
- salex89 7y agoCan't say about new ones, but after a couple of years of working on a huge Python project, I would accept rewriting it in Java without a whim. I have equal experience in Python and Java by now. Funny thing, I returned from my vacation a few months ago, and started writing my first code after it. Of course, I was more concerned with thinking what am I writing instead of how. Then I looked up and noticed I started typing Java instead of Python. And that's three years after the last time I've written some Java code.
- kevan 7y agoPlenty of teams within Amazon
- pron 7y agoOh, just Apple, Amazon, Google, Netflix and likely every hospital, utility company, police force, military, or bank you depend on. And the people programming the robot swarms that pack your groceries (https://www.infoq.com/presentations/java-robot-swarms/ https://www.infoq.com/presentations/java-robot-swarms/).