3 ms·
> Hayek is arguing that no centralised agent has perfect information. The author is arguing that Amazon is approaching the stage when it would have perfect info
by pdonis 7y ago
> Hayek is arguing that no centralised agent has perfect information. The author is arguing that Amazon is approaching the stage when it would have perfect information about the consumers it serves.
This statement in the article is a huge misstatement.
First, Amazon only has information about the goods it sells. There are many things it doesn't sell, and many things that it can't sell. There are huge supply chains behind the products it sells that it does not see. There are also many things of value that are not exchanged with money.
Second, to the extent Amazon does have information about its customers, it has that information because of those customers' buying decisions. In other words, it has exactly the information that Hayek says a market participant has, and no more: the price at which other market participants will buy whatever quantity of one's products are sold.
- morningseagulls 7y ago>> Hayek is arguing that no centralised agent has perfect information. The author is arguing that Amazon is approaching the stage when it would have perfect information about the consumers it serves. >This statement in the article is a huge misstatement. At least blame the right person: me. The above statement is a paraphrase of what I thought the author's argument was. >First, Amazon only has information about the goods it sells. >There are huge supply chains behind the products it sells that it does not see. And it is in the process of acquiring more information. Amazon isn't just a retailer anymore: its main source of operating income is now AWS[0]. Also, dredmorbius has pointed out[1] that Amazon is doing vertical integration with its Amazon Business offering[2]. >There are many things it doesn't sell, and many things that it can't sell. This is irrelevant, because these "many things" exist in a market outside of Amazon's "jurisdiction". Even in the historical centrally planned economies, these "many things" also existed. >There are also many things of value that are not exchanged with money. And they are getting rarer and rarer, because monetisation is now the Great Project. >In other words, it has exactly the information that Hayek says a market participant has, and no more: the price at which other market participants will buy whatever quantity of one's products are sold. Actually, Amazon has more information than a single market participant has. Since it is the market because it is a marketplace-as-a-service, it has exactly the information that Hayek says the sum total of all market participants have. This invalidates Hayek's argument that no centralised agent can possibly collect that much information. This point is what I believe the author of the article is trying to make. [0] https://www.zdnet.com/article/in-2018-aws-delivered-most-of-amazons-operating-income/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/in-2018-aws-delivered-most-of-... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21306655 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21306655 [2] https://www.amazon.com/b2b/info/amazon-business https://www.amazon.com/b2b/info/amazon-business
- pdonis 7y ago> The above statement is a paraphrase of what I thought the author's argument was. Fair enough. > Amazon has more information than a single market participant has. Since it is the market because it is a marketplace-as-a-service, it has exactly the information that Hayek says the sum total of all market participants have. No, it doesn't. It has all the information that a large market participant has--i.e., a market participant that has a very large number of transactions with a very large number of other market participants. Hayek was perfectly well aware that such market participants existed (after all, such participants existed in his day--for example, Standard Oil). But Amazon's information is still limited to information that a market participant can have: namely, as I said, the prices at which the various goods it sells are sold. It does not have any more information than that. It has information about a lot more transactions than most other market participants, but the information it has about each transaction is the same as what the other participant in the transaction has, no more.
- morningseagulls 7y ago>Hayek was perfectly well aware that such market participants existed (after all, such participants existed in his day--for example, Standard Oil). And Hayek did mention monopolies or "coordinated industries" as a "halfway house" between centrally planned economies and free markets. Sure. >But Amazon's information is still limited to information that a market participant can have: namely, as I said, the prices at which the various goods it sells are sold. It does not have any more information than that. Actually, Amazon does collect and process information that a market participant wouldn't normally have: consumer preferences. Hayek argued that a central planner wouldn't be able to suck up the decentralised information embodied in every market participant. However, what Amazon is doing is mining the data it has about a consumer's purchase history, as well as the responses the consumer gave to recommendations made by its recommender engine. That is a lot more information than what most market participants would normally have access to. Now, Hayek has outlined what he thinks is needed to construct a "rational economic order" in the beginning of "The Use of Knowledge in Society": 1) "If we possess all the relevant information", 2) "if we can start out from a given system of preferences", 3) "if we command complete knowledge of available means". Unlike the monopolies of old, which may have 1) to some extent, Amazon also has 2), and is trying to acquire 3) with its Amazon Business offering. So its capabilities are arguably an improvement over the capabilities of the old monopolies.