9 ms·
The link between middle-wage jobs, wage inequality, and worker welfare
- sysbin 7y ago"The current Western psychiatric wisdom states that suicide is the result of mental disorder in 98% (1) or even 100% (2) of cases. However, a number of recent studies (3–5) have reported that, in Asian countries, mental disorder has been found in less than 50% of those who completed suicide. In the late 19th century, Emil Durkheim, a sociologist, published (6) important observations. Durkheim found that suicide was primarily a function of social circumstances; he stated that people suicide when they are not supported by or well integrated into the society, and that mental disorder was relatively less important. The majority of his observations have been supported: for example, he found that marital breakdown frequently led to suicide, particularly among males, and this has been repeatedly demonstrated (7)." Source - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3431736/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3431736/
- finishground 7y agoGlad I came across this! I just started reading a book titled ‘The Origins Of Happiness’ by David Smail, which puts forth a more broad thesis of mental illness, but very comparable. https://www.amazon.com/Origins-Unhappiness-Understanding-Personal-Distress/dp/1782202870?SubscriptionId=AKIAILSHYYTFIVPWUY6Q&tag=duckduckgo-fpas-20&linkCode=xm2&camp=2025&creative=165953&creativeASIN=1782202870 https://www.amazon.com/Origins-Unhappiness-Understanding-Per...
- mamcx 7y agoInteresting. That mean that low/medium mental disorders are not big deal in an environment of stability/happiness. "If you are ugly, and everyone love you, it don't matter!" I remember this...
- jmpman 7y agoI’ve read that politicians pushed the H1B program to drive down wages in the STEM fields, in order to reduce perceived wage inequality. The top 1/10 of 1% can remain hidden if the bottom 50% aren’t seeing the much more visible top 10% driving their BMWs around.
- RhodesianHunter 7y agoThat seems somewhat absurd. It's far more likely that they did it simply to reduce costs and increase hiring
- dadarepublic 7y agoWhy not both? Why not do a thing that has multiple benefits? If doing something to my advantage, also has a side effect that is also to my advantage seems like even more of a reason to do that something.
- dahdum 7y agoSkilled immigration is an economic home run, those opposed to it are similar to the NIMBY’s in the Bay Area that vote down all new housing so their home values rise. IMHO, there is no conspiratorial reason politicians pushed the program, it was common sense. H1B is a flawed half measure of a program because of upper middle class voters.
- jariel 7y ago"the Bay Area that vote down all new housing so their home values rise." Every community (local, regional, national) has a right to decide their future. If some locality doesn't want to be New York or Hong Kong, that's fine, it's their choice. There are vast, vast areas of the US that are not super high rent/income, or even totally under developed. Even around the Bay Area. 19th/20th century growth strategies are not consistent with sustainability in most ways. Also - any policy which has the effect of displacing local workers for foreign workers primarily as a function of wage should be totally outlawed. A lot of H1B is not this obviously, but a lot of it is. H1B might need a more nuanced approach in order for it to be a real net-gain and not just a 'labour input cost' policy.
- dexen 7y ago>Skilled immigration is an economic home run Your response is tangential to the original point. OP asserts correctly that increasing supply of labor depresses wages, by lowering the negotiating leverage. Your response handwaves it away with "skilled immigration is better for the whole economy". Sorry to burst your bubble - this is a thread about balancing the wages / profits split. OP is right; the higher the supply of labor, the lower the price of labor, thus leaving higher proportion of the surplus as profits. Aka the dreaded inequality. It's fine to prefer profit over wages, if that's how you make your living. But let's not pretend we're for increasing wages while in fact for increasing profit.
- finishground 7y agoAn interesting fact is that there were a couple of 19th century economists who predicted everything here. The Soviet Union took their works for-granted by abusing them, and the United States took their works for-granted by ignoring them. The world might be better off to just not take those works for-granted at all.
- andrewtbham 7y agoUS inequality is up but global inequality is down. https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty
- danans 7y ago> US inequality is up but global inequality is down. Not sure if you are implying otherwise, but the reduction in global inequality doesn't necessarily require growth in US inequality, although that's the form that this has taken. Growth in US inequality is to an extent a policy choice: US GDP has grown a huge amount during the same period, but the same period the majority of those gains have gone to those in the top fractions of 1% of the wealth distribution.
- solidsnack9000 7y agoThe conclusion is that computerization and automation are not the root of the change, which is at least contrary to popular wisdom. In an era of increasing returns to capital, relying on wages may ultimately be a losing strategy.
- dvduval 7y agoThomas Picketty did great research in this area. The way I understood part of his theory is that the rate at which the value of wealth increases is faster then the rate at which wages increase. In other words, those people who own things like land and factories see the value of those things increase faster than workers see their wages increase.
- bmurphy1976 7y agoAnd that cycle usually ends when a few people get their heads chopped off and things reset. It would be nice if we could figure out a better way to spread the wealth without costly and violent revolutions.
- heavyset_go 7y agoThere needs to be equity in employment relationships. A society that's stratified into two classes, the ownership class and the working class, will always result in the cycle you identified.
- WalterBright 7y agoThis time in history is the easiest ever for anyone to be owning the means of production, via the democratization of the stock market.
- Thlom 7y agoSure, but the normal working class hero have limited capital and limited time to research and limited knowledge of the stock market. Sure, he can own 0.00002% of a company, but in the end it doesn't really matter. He still doesn't have control over the means of production of which he puts his own labor into. He's still dependent on his salary which the true owner of the means of production can take away at any time.
- rayiner 7y agoOne of the things I’ve learned as I started digging into wage inequality statistics is that performing this data analysis is extremely complicated. Demographics have changed dramatically between then and now. The labor force participation rate for women has nearly doubled from 1950 to today. The US keeps income statistics on a per household basis, and marriage rates and household sizes have declined dramatically. The percentage of the population that is immigrants has tripled since 1970. The age distribution has changed, as well as college attendance rates (four years where young people are earning no income). Racial distributions have changed, which creates complex effects. (Phenomena that are better explained as racial discrimination show up as income inequality. Also, the median ages of people of different races varies quite dramatically, from 28 for African Americans to 43 for white non-Hispanic Americans. So some of what you might characterize as racial inequality actually ends up being age inequality.) The shift from hourly factory work to salaried service jobs, the create of tax income like the EITC, etc., all make these analyses extremely complicated. To isolate what you might think of as income inequality due to structural economic factors, you’d want something like individual lifetime income adjusted by race, immigration status, and gender. I have yet to see anything that thoroughly adjusts for all of these confounding factors.
- refurb 7y agoDespite not always agreeing with Raynier, his posts are always well thought out. Glad to see this at the top. In terms of demographics, the baby boomers caused a big bulge in the distribution of the population. As they age, their earnings and overall wealth grow as well (take a look at income versus age). What happens when you have a disproportionate chunk of the population get wealthy? Income inequality grows. If this is indeed a factor, once baby boomers die off, we’d likely see a decrease in inequality.
- IkmoIkmo 7y agoRan into this a lot myself. So far I haven't been able to get very far to consolidate all these variables. Whenever I see threads pointing to economic growth or decline, I'm left saying there are tons of confounding factors, but without being able to offer the right answer. If you have any good reading to point to, please let me know. It's one of the things I'd love to have a good answer to, and that should be able to be answered to some extent, but isn't. Moreover I feel even many top economists routinely invoke extremely simplified single-variable perspectives (e.g. average wages per worker, or average household income) which indeed leaves out so many confounding factors that I've almost lost my expectation/hope that people even consider this kind of stuff... Only in academic papers which look to study something specific, are these confounders taken into account. But in general studies of economic growth or changes in or comparisons of economic wellbeing of various demographic subgroups, it seems the simple-perspective prevails. I get that many of these discussions are inherently political, thus susceptible to cherry-picking perspectives, but I'm still surprised there isn't some standard method so far that is more complex than charting 'household income for xyz'. Any pointers to good literature is most welcome, and thanks for posting!
- md2be 7y agoThe oldest millennial is now 38. This group - now the largest as a percentage - will see wage growth year over year for the next 15 years for three reasons 1) their skills improve year after year 2) employers will have a harder time replacing them - and will pay them not to leave 3) productivity is about to accelerate after a decade of flat productivity.
- pas 7y agoCould someone explain the symmetry in figure 2? Why top-bottom is so strongly linked seemingly completely ignoring the middle two quartiles?