6 ms·
The most important thing to know about depression is that it is an illness. It has no moral dimension. Get treatment. People telling you to buck up and get hold
by ncmncm 7y ago
The most important thing to know about depression is that it is an illness. It has no moral dimension. Get treatment. People telling you to buck up and get hold of yourself are much, much worse than useless.
The second most important thing to know is that "depression" is a label for at least a half-dozen, probably more, unrelated illnesses. What helps with one does nothing for another.
The third is that no matter what else you do, getting enough (but not too much) sleep, and enough exercise, are essential. Lack of either makes all varieties worse. But if you can't, do whatever you can. Sometimes just getting up is a triumph. Savor each.
Psychiatrists have no other way to determine which kind you have than to try various meds and see if any work. For some varieties no med works. Often a med does no good below a certain dosage level, or until you have been taking it for a month. Some work immediately. Most have annoying side effects that may gradually fade.
Many people have more than one kind, and need to treat both or all. It may be combined with other problems like anxiety.
Exercising, sleeping, and eating right can be hard, even prohibitively hard, when you are ill. Don't beat yourself up over being ill. Do whatever you can, now, and plan to do more when you can.
- anm89 7y agoI hear the "depression is an illness" trope repeated over and over but I still fail to understand what it means. I'm sure for some definition of the word illness it's true. But it's certainly not an illness in the way a cold or malaria or shingles or cystic fibrosis are illnesses. Those things can be objectively diagnosed. They entail physical measurable changes to a person's body. Depression is a set of guidelines in a book that ask vague subjective questions about how someone perceives the world. And then if the person decides you have it you have it. If they don't you dont. This has very little to do with the first scenario. I'm not trying to trivialize depression. I think it is very real and very serious. But I think the "illness" rehtoric is at best innacurate and at worst seriously misleading and distracting to people who have serious issues to deal with.
- syndacks 7y agoJust because you can't measure something doesn't mean it's not there. Perhaps we don't have the tools or knowledge yet to measure depression, like countless other human ailments of the past that are now treatable.
- ncmncm 7y agoOnce all fevers were "ague". Now we have flu (dozens of strains), malaria, encephalitis, toxemia, etc., with a different treatment for each. Depression is still at the "ague" stage. For certain varieties, certain medications completely resolve them. For some, a treatment hasn't been identified. Approval of treatments is crippled by lack of diagnostic tools, so to test one, it has to be used on people who have all kinds, and then it only helps the small minority of them who have what it's good for. Statistically, one that works 100% for the actual illness it treats looks like it helps only 10-15% of the sample.
- tim333 7y agoThere are different types of depression. It can be an illness caused by some brain imbalance, or it can be a normal human reaction to things being a bit depressing. For the first maybe seek medical help and for the second maybe try to improve your situation eg. go somewhere sunny, get a better job, make more friends etc. Also things like gratitude journals, DIY CBT and so on can help with the second. It the US there seems a tendency to overmedicalize and put people on antidepressant pills for life although they have no more effect than taking up exercise for example.
- currymj 7y agothis is equally true of, say, schizophrenia — there’s no physical test for it as far as I know, just questionnaires about how someone perceives the world. but i don’t think anyone would argue it’s not a biological disease at this point, even if we don’t yet know what biological parameters to measure.
- brudgers 7y agoDiagnosis of depression is clinical. Self reporting via standardized questions is an ordinary medical method. "Where does it hurt?" "When did it start?" "Is there a history of heart disease in your family?." "When did your baby start crying?" 'Illness' provides a framework for recognition and treatment. The book with the guidelines is medical not religious. The guidelines are guided by empiricism not revelation. Treatments are selected based on statistics rather than authority. There's general agreement that the book's content might be wrong. There's a process for changing it and the expectation that it will be rewritten. Criteria for diagnosing depression in the DSM include behavioral "thinking of suicide," physically measurable "weight loss," and general well being "fatigue." The suicide criterion is more conducive to empirical confirmation than "headache" or "joint pain."
- ExtremePopcorn 7y ago> I'm not trying to trivialize depression. As someone who has been catatonically depressed for a couple years now, I'm not so sure about this! People with chronic pain also often can't identify any physical source, but obviously you would never start posting "is this really an illness though?" or "aren't we distracting and misleading people??" in a thread about that. The undercurrent of your post is that depressed people need to snap out of it, and falling back on the "illness" label reduces personal responsibility. Trust me, many people feel like imposters claiming they have depression, despite being completely non-functional. Thanks but no thanks to this proposed contribution to the discourse. Are you really here to understand, or is it just to judge? Want some MRIs and EKGs of depressed brains?
- anm89 7y ago> undercurrent of your post is that depressed people need to snap out of it, Please point to where I say that. I explicitly do not say that. That's not an undercurrent because I don't believe it. I do also believe that people don't have zero agency in this problem. There is SOME ability and necessity for people to work on these types of problems. That's what therapy with a therapist is right? And that does differentiate depression from tuberculosis which cannot ever be improved by sitting down and talking about it.
- ncmncm 7y agoVisiting a professional is generally a necessary step in recovering from tuberculosis. In that way it is not different from depression. In most forms of depression, talking with someone and doing nothing else is guaranteed to do no good. In that way they do not differ from tuberculosis.
- ExtremePopcorn 7y agoOkay, my mistake for getting dragged into the archetypal HN argument. It's clear you cannot be convinced. Your original point - that depression has no biomarkers and is extremely subjective - has been proven wrong by a couple others and you've shown no gratitude or interest in this information. Only replying where you think there's an argument to be won. Maybe you, some random person on Hacker News, are not in fact smarter than the medical consensus? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc
- belltaco 7y agoScience is getting there. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5436791/table/t1-ndt-13-1245/?report=objectonly https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5436791/table/t...
- psv1 7y agoYou write this: > I'm not trying to trivialize depression. And then: > at worst seriously misleading and distracting to people who have serious issues to deal with. Implying that it isn't a serious issue.
- anm89 7y agoI literally used the phrase "serious issue" in the proceeding sentence to describe the situation. ??? I'd be very curious to hear this one explained. I'm totally baffled.
- dmos62 7y agoYou are mistaken about depression not having observable effect on the body. I wrote a post about that; it's a direct sibling to your original post. Your point is a bit conflicted. Like this person pointed out, it seems that you're saying that it's serious and not that serious at the same time. However, I think that the observation you wanted to convey wasn't about the comparative seriousness of depression, but rather that it's in some sense in a different realm than for example AIDS or shingles, even if the realm of some of its effects are similar (which you argued against, but you're wrong). And, I sympathize with that. Depression does seem to be made of a different cloth, but it's quite hard to elaborate further, and I won't get into it here.
- ncmncm 7y agoIt is odd to mention shingles in this context, as depression is a very common symptom of herpes infection, actually fixed by antiviral medication. So, even on its own terms, the argument is incoherent and, not to put too fine a point on it, wrong.
- quickthrower2 7y agoRe Exercise: unless you have unexplained fatigue symptoms, where exercise levels nay need to be managed carefully. Not none but not HiiT either!
- slothtrop 7y agoTreatment for depression ought not begin and end with medication. It's symptomatic. In the vast majority of cases, it means some large part of your lifestyle's gone wrong. The common advice today is tantamount to ignoring fist lines of defense in favor of just treating symptoms indefinitely, because it feeds the pharma machine. That's not to say medication doesn't have its place. It's that suggesting we eschew all other measures in favor of medication is ridiculous.
- ncmncm 7y ago> In the vast majority of cases, it means some large part of your lifestyle's gone wrong. It must be nice to know so much about everyone around you, without needing to actually obtain any facts at all. Is it possible that changes to exercise, diet, time outdoors, or latitude of residence could help in some cases? Maybe. Is there anywhere near enough data to attribute a "vast majority of cases" to these causes? No.
- dmos62 7y ago> In the vast majority of cases, it means some large part of your lifestyle's gone wrong. That's misleading. Lifestyle changes can have a significant positive effect, but that's also misleading, because you have to account for the often insurmountable inertia that old behaviors have. Furthermore, the most reliable predictor of manic depression in later life is more than 2 traumatic experiences before age 7. I might be misquoting the figures slightly: it might be 3, not 2, or 10, not 7. However, the point I'm making is that in many cases saying that depression is caused by erroneous lifestyle is plain wrong. I agree with you on medication, it has it's place, but it's hardly the end of the story. I personally don't take it, because I feel that my case is more suited to a different therapy, though I feel a bit silly about never having tried it. I think that one of the best things you can do is try a lot of things, to see what works for you.
- dmos62 7y agoI agree that depression is an umbrella term, and saying that it's not a real illness is ignorant. It's like saying PTSD isn't an illness. I periodically experience bouts of (what I call) depression, which I'd summarize as an intense anger that's oriented towards one's self. Paradoxically, it's very intense and at the same time it shuts me down. An analogy would be shoveling sand and cement into a drive train. I won't get into the typical "how to fix it" part of this discourse, but I think it can be useful for people who have trouble sympathizing with people who experience depressive episodes to know what are some of the things that one experiences. I think it's also good for one experiencing these things to be able to reflect on what's happening, to, at the very least, get some distance. So the episodes, in my case, have very clear "clinical" symptoms. Blood flow to the limbs is reduced severely, I'll often be on the verge of shivering with cold, similarly to what happens when you have a fever; motoric ability is severely reduced: you'll be tripping on things, dropping things; reaction time is severely reduced: for example, you're likely to not catch something that's thrown at you; appetite loss; glaring morbidity; difficulty sleeping; a strong, general feeling of discomfort in the body, a bit like recovering from a physical shock, like an automotive accident. For me, the thing lasts for 2 to 5 days, and happens every few weeks, rarely more than twice a month.