2 ms·
>If they removed the notch, literally no one would want the version with the notch, because it’s so plainly and universally undesirable. Are we talking about a
by Hamuko 7y ago
>If they removed the notch, literally no one would want the version with the notch, because it’s so plainly and universally undesirable.
Are we talking about a magical scenario where they have figured out how the minimise all of the hardware in the notch so that there's virtually no bezel on top? Or about a scenario where they take away the notch and all of the hardware in it? Because I'm not exactly sure how the sales pitch for an iPhone 11 without Face ID, proximity sensor, ambient light sensor, speaker or front-facing camera would go. And if they just deleted the notch by making it a regular bezel, I don't think that would be a sales hit either. "The all new iPhone 11 - now without selfies!"
A hypothetical either-or scenario where the other scenario has literally no drawback is a pretty dumb one. And as far as I can tell, that's exactly what this argument is. It's like saying that no one would buy an iPhone with a 3000 mAh battery if they could get a 6000 mAh in the same packaging. But if you introduce another variable, like the iPhone being as thick as the Nokia 3310, or 5% of shipped phones catching on fire, then someone might actually go for the 3000 mAh.
- smcl 7y agoIf you keep reading, the author goes on to describe how they think the screens which stretch to the edges are a bit unnecessary. So it’s not that they want to remove the notch and have the screen stretch to the top ... but to remove the notch by having the screen stop just below it (like the SE, and all pre-Notch iPhones)
- Hamuko 7y agoBut I don't think there's actually a market for that. The display on the sides of the notch have things in them that you want to have visible anyways. Why not have a bit more screen? It's not like the iPhone 11 would be any cheaper without it. Some people have used wallpaper trickery to make the notch less visible while still getting the benefit of the time and status indicators being out of the main display area. http://osxdaily.com/2017/11/06/hide-iphone-x-notch-wallpaper-trick/ http://osxdaily.com/2017/11/06/hide-iphone-x-notch-wallpaper...
- smcl 7y agoAgain, you should read the article. These are things the raised and discussed there - the wallpaper trickery particularly