3 ms·
"an abrogation of moral responsibility to form, apply, and maintain our own value systems." I think it's a big (and almost certainly invalid) assumption that i
by perl4ever 7y ago
"an abrogation of moral responsibility to form, apply, and maintain our own value systems."
I think it's a big (and almost certainly invalid) assumption that in the absence of metrics, people "apply and maintain" a consistent value system. It seems to me inconsistent with a belief in the destructive effect of the wrong metrics.
If you think that metrics lead to bad results, it's completely inconsistent to suggest that not having metrics is better. When you have metrics, the harm comes from people ignoring what really should be optimized in favor of what is being measured. If you don't have any metrics, then you're only decreasing the pressure to do whatever may be the right thing.
It's like, no matter how bad the government is, the only solution is better government, not eliminating it.
So, I think your general attitude is ironically capturing the essence of a common intellectual failing of the people you are stereotyping. You know, the glib libertarian tech worker.
- inimino 7y ago> in the absence of metrics, people "apply and maintain" a consistent value system What on earth makes you think I'm making this assumption? I never said anything of the sort. I said that people are abrogating their responsibility to do difficult work (figuring out if the ship is going in the right direction or not) by trying to offload this onto metrics, which are theoretically objective and unbiased. Nowhere did I ever say anything about what people not over-using metrics are doing. > If you don't have any metrics, then you're only decreasing the pressure to do whatever may be the right thing. That is not necessarily true at all. Having no metrics at all, just like having no government, means that you must fill the void with something. You must decide for yourself how to act, probably based on a subjective judgement of what the situation is combined with your personal values.
- perl4ever 7y ago"Having no metrics at all, just like having no government, means that you must fill the void with something." How can one "fill the void" without measuring anything? Personal values may vary, but I can't see the concept of determining the consequences of your actions as being an optional one of them. It seems to me that if you are definitely rejecting that, then you have no personal values. Even if you say you do.
- inimino 7y agoPlease be careful with your terminology here. When we talk about metrics, especially in a business context, we are talking about numerical quantities that can be tracked and unambiguously measured. A metric that can't be measured, or that nobody agrees on the measurement of, is no good as a metric, in this context. Are we agreed on that part of the definition of a metric? > determining the consequences of your actions That is an entirely different thing. > measuring anything And that is yet another entirely separate concept. You can weigh a course of action without measuring anything. > It seems to me that if you are definitely rejecting that, then you have no personal values. In most situations in life, you must make a decision without any chance to know the results of your actions. Can you know in advance the result of picking a career, or taking a job, getting married, moving to another country, or voting for a particular candidate? Of course not. The number of decisions in life that are repeated, and where a numerical, measurable value is available to guide your decision making over time (which is what is meant by tracking metrics in a business context) are a vanishingly small minority of the decisions we must make. Unless you calculate a utility function before crossing the street, or having breakfast, I don't think you really mean to argue for what you appear to be arguing for.
- perl4ever 7y agoI don't think that we're on the same wavelength and no, we are not at all agreed on what a metric is, but here's a link to a book that might be interesting: https://www.amazon.com/How-Measure-Anything-Intangibles-Business/dp/1118539273/ https://www.amazon.com/How-Measure-Anything-Intangibles-Busi...
- inimino 7y agoI don't know your working definition of a metric, but if you think it is coextensive with "determining the consequences of your actions" then I'm sure it's not the right definition in this context. If you think it's necessary to measure before choosing a right course of action in every circumstance, I think you'll find that belief dissolves under a little scrutiny. From the reviews, the book seems to have some light statistics and introduction to Monte Carlo methods. I don't think it would have much to teach me about statistics or philosophy. It might be useful for someone without a background in statistics who is forced to navigate a business environment where people value metrics above all else, but I'm arguing against such environments.