4 ms·
Why does there even need to be a cloud service? Why does my lightbulb need a cloud service? My thermostat? My security camera? If these so-called smart devices
by ryandrake 7y ago
Why does there even need to be a cloud service? Why does my lightbulb need a cloud service? My thermostat? My security camera? If these so-called smart devices really need some service running another computer (rather than the computer on the device itself), why can’t it be my own computer on my LAN, behind my “no uploading” firewall rules?
I had a dropcam for a while. Infuriating device. It records video, uploads it to its cloud service, then when I want to watch the video, the player downloads it back from that service through my same internet connection! what kind of bonehead decided that was a good use of my bandwidth? Why can’t I just connect locally directly to the device and stream video from it? It’s as if someone said “well we have lots of cloud engineers here, so we obviously need to write a cloud service!” without regard to whether it was needed. Or more cynically, they said “We could make it stream video locally but then we couldn’t offer a monthly cloud service for sweet recurring revenue.”
- heavenlyblue 7y agoI don’t think anything in our society stops from creating an organisation which could be responsible for creating open standards of running all of these cloud services ourselves. Apart from nextcloud, self-hosted social networks and sandstorm - what else is there that solves similar problems? So the question is why does it not exist yet?
- icebraining 7y agoSomething like https://iot.mozilla.org https://iot.mozilla.org ?
- hos234 7y agoThink of it this way - Megacorps once upon a time realized they had a lot of lavatories not really being used. So they decided to start renting them out. That became a profitable business. Thanks to how Corporate Robots are programmed, the moment a profitable business is spotted, the next move is to Scale up. They got a bit carried away thanks to Moores law making lavatory building cheap, especially if you buy a million at a time and so now we have town sized constructs of just lavatories. And all those lavatories need infinite quantities of piss and shit to justify their existence. Conduct hackathons. Fund incubators. Hire the best and brightest and it's possible to get populations to ramp up piss and shit generation. It then takes armies of sales and marketing drones zigzagging the planet day and night incentivizing orgs and people to ditch their own loos. The stagnating transport industry (Big Telco) woke up when they noticed people taking shuttles to Mega Loo Plaza and started competing with each other to upgrade their own transport infra all over the world. A confluence of all these factory take us right back to where we started. A lavatory excess. But don't worry the Corporate Robot class is on the case. The goal is to get people to piss and shit 24x7 to utilize that excess (you will notice people who produce a lot piss and shit are encouraged). And things seem to be going well. And ofcourse you can use your own loo at home. They are very cheap these days.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- xt00 7y agoInteresting.. would be cool if 99% of the data was not uploaded but while you are on the go you could optionally have it send you a list of hot spots in the video stream that you could select from.. then that would send to you potentially without a cloud in the middle.. local home servers are great if they are basically bulletproof... I always have the issue that my home server for some reason randomly reboots or Comcast blocks a port or the persistent vpn suddenly disconnects and won’t reconnect.. I’ve just not been able to figure out a bulletproof method so that when I’m away from home I can rely upon it working..
- tinus_hn 7y agoLightbulbs need a cloud service if you reliably and easily want to be able to control them while you’re not connected to your home network.