5 ms·
Yet another post on HN about a company that needs to be broken up because they are big in some made up market. Now are we going to define a monopoly as the “Pop
by scarface74 7y ago
Yet another post on HN about a company that needs to be broken up because they are big in some made up market. Now are we going to define a monopoly as the “Pop Culture” market.
Would you also like the government to “build a market” so that everyone can have all the software they want and have the government decide what a fair amount for software is?
- echelon 7y agoDisney films are generic, cookie cutter formulas designed for mass appeal and ROI. They buy everything they can and then force theaters to show their films in the most desirable weekend spots. They're soaking up all the money and pushing the smaller players out. They're now trying to eat Netflix. Not to mention that they follow Beijing's content directives. We should take a serious look at balancing the scales. If we expired Star Wars' copyright after 20 years, others could use the license and develop their own take. Disney would be forced to innovate and pursue new IP creation. It would be good for competition. This is just my own thought on the matter. Maybe it's wrong. I happen to think it would improve the status quo and actually result in market growth as you'd need new to hire more creatives. Novel content in turn results in more interest.
- scarface74 7y agoEvery commercial product is designed for maximum ROI. They buy everything they can and then force theaters to show their films in the most desirable weekend spots. You really think movie theaters would rather show movies that don’t fill it? They're soaking up all the money and pushing the smaller players out. Ever heard of Blumhouse? Their entire business model is to make low budget movies that cost under $10 million and they usually have a higher ROI than Disney movies. If we expired Star Wars' copyright after 20 years, others could use the license and develop their own take. Disney would be forced to innovate and pursue new IP creation. It would be good for competition. Why not force other people to innovate instead of building on top of Star Wars?
- echelon 7y ago> Every commercial product is designed for maximum ROI. Not true with art. > You really think movie theaters would rather show movies that don’t fill it? Disney takes a larger cut per screen, so the theater actually makes less money on Disney films. If they don't show Disney films on their best screens, they'll lose the right to show any Disney films. It's extortion. [1] [2] > Ever heard of Blumhouse? Their entire business model is to make low budget movies that cost under $10 million and they usually have a higher ROI than Disney movies. These are horror films. That genre has always been cheap to film. Blumhouse is a great businessman. I don't think this model fits for every genre, eg. period pieces and art house cinema. > Why not force other people to innovate instead of building on top of Star Wars? I'm not saying that they shouldn't. Disney should start innovating instead of stretching its licenses over and over. Pixar has become garbage since Disney took over. They're not going to make risky films like Logan with their IP, either. I'm doing everything I can to get into this market, and I'm terrified of having to compete with this juggernaut. If they're going to play hard ball with their IP, I'm going to lobby for looser IP protections. It's good for consumers and creatives anyway. [1] https://mashable.com/2017/11/01/star-wars-last-jedi-theaters-disney/ https://mashable.com/2017/11/01/star-wars-last-jedi-theaters... [2] https://qz.com/1479408/small-theater-chains-worry-a-mid-century-rule-is-all-that-stands-between-them-and-extinction/ https://qz.com/1479408/small-theater-chains-worry-a-mid-cent...
- scarface74 7y agoDisney takes a larger cut per screen, so the theater actually makes less money on Disney films. If they don't show Disney films on their best screens, they'll lose the right to show any Disney films. It's extortion. [1] [2] Movie theaters have never made most of their money from ticket sales. They make money from concessions.
- echelon 7y ago> Movie theaters have never made most of their money from ticket sales. They make money from concessions. We're getting nitpicky here. Theaters still make money through ticket sales, though the studios take most of the revenue [1]. Sometimes theaters earn over 50% of revenue. It depends on the film. Disney takes more than anyone, leaving barely anything for theaters. Better not sneak in any snacks to their films or you'll be stiffing the theater! But the bottom line is that Disney dictates what gets shown and when. If theaters don't give up as many screens as Disney wants, they'll lose their rights to Disney films outright. And that isn't fair. [1] https://theweek.com/articles/647394/when-buy-movie-ticket-where-does-that-money https://theweek.com/articles/647394/when-buy-movie-ticket-wh...
- anoncake 7y ago> Would you also like the government to “build a market” so that everyone can have all the software they want Yes, of course I would like the democratically elected government to run the economy in a sane way. > and have the government decide what a fair amount for software is? No, that would be absurd. The fair amount for software is equal to its marginal cost which is zero.
- scarface74 7y agoSo how should we pay for software developers? Should software as service products that have hosting cost also be free?
- anoncake 7y ago> So how should we pay for software developers? Taxes, of course. That's how we fund things where individually charging people does not make sense. > Should software as service products that have hosting cost also be free? Generally not, why?
- scarface74 7y agoSo now we are going to charge higher taxes to subsidize software developers. Are we also going to have a centralized “5 Year Plan” for the economy? How has this worked for China and Russia. They realized decades ago that this didn’t work.
- anoncake 7y ago> So now we are going to charge higher taxes to subsidize software developers. What's wrong with "subsidizing", aka paying, software developers? > Are we also going to have a centralized “5 Year Plan” for the economy? How has this worked for China and Russia. They realized decades ago that this didn’t work. The lack of creativity on a website supposedly populated by engineers keeps astounding me. Hell, you don't even need creativity to be aware that public broadcasters exist. Or to recognize that computing and communication technology has somewhat improved in the past 30 years. Considering that the planners of the eastern block had to greatly simplify their plans and still weren't able to finish their calculations within 5 years, the state capitalist economy worked remarkably well.
- Teever 7y agoThe government built this market! It wouldn't exist without copyright law or the perpetual extension of it!