6 ms·
This is strictly worse than cable. Streaming in the 2010s was a breath of fresh air. You could find everything on one platform, watch it at your leisure, and p
by echelon 7y ago
This is strictly worse than cable.
Streaming in the 2010s was a breath of fresh air. You could find everything on one platform, watch it at your leisure, and pay way less than cable.
Now we're going to have to pay more AND switch between nine different apps with broken UIs.
This is god awful. All of this because of greed and a lack of regulation.
We need to campaign for limited copyright (20 years), and build services like Spotify that have everything and merely pay the rights holders.
Disney needs to be broken up. They own 90% of American pop culture. They're going to begin protection racketing theaters and dumbing down everything to appease the masses (and foreign governments).
God, I hate what the Internet is becoming.
- solipsism 7y agoYou don't have to do anything. You just feel the need to watch everything that can be watched. If you don't want to pay for every service, you should just reset your expectations.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThat's not how it works. For one, it's the age-old anticonsumer situation, but a fully distributed edition. People value movies and shows by title, not by distributor. Platforms aggregate orthogonally to that. The end result is, even if you ranked all the movies/shows by how much you wanted to that and restricted yourself to top 10, you'll likely end up having to subscribe to all the mainstream platforms to get them. Secondly, wrt. not having to watch anything, you sort-of do. Popular entertainment becomes popular culture, and if you want to participate in the society and build relationships with other people, you kind of have to be at least aware of some of the current offerings of that popular culture.
- zzzcpan 7y agoEntertainment is not really pop culture and is diverse enough these days, thanks to the internet, that you can easily not find a single tv show or a movie to talk about with someone.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoWith a someone, yes. But the role of pop culture has always been to facilitate conversations in group settings, especially groups when not all participants know each other well.
- solipsism 7y agoPopular entertainment becomes popular culture, and if you want to participate in the society and build relationships with other people, you kind of have to be at least aware of some of the current offerings of that popular culture. Oh come on. Are you really claiming that if you can talk with your friends about Stranger Things, but not Game of Thrones because you don't have HBO, then you face some kind of serious impediment to participating in society? That strikes me as completely ridiculous. Customers don't like a big monolithic bundle because the single bill is too expensive. Customers also don't like a la carte content (which is available on any number of platforms, including Google and Amazon and Apple) because each individual bill is too expensive. Customers also don't like medium sized bundlings, because when things get split up across different bundles then people feel left out, and everyone feels the need to watch everything. So what's your proposal? It's not like the market isn't trying to cater to customers here. Do you propose we pass laws that restrict companies from creating exclusive content? Or should we pass laws that restrict content from costing more than a specific amount? Will we also have to pass laws to keep the quality up in that case? Why? Just because customers insatiably want and want and want? There are lots of real problems in the world for us to solve. This is not one of them.
- anoncake 7y ago1. If cultural works are important, it's important that people can access them. 2. If they aren't, let's get rid of them and reallocate resources to more important things. 3. If allocating resources is the job of the market, then the market has decided that these cultural works are important. GOTO 1.
- solipsism 7y agoWho's talking about cultural works that people can't access? What we're talking about is how much money they can access them for, and how many services they have to sign up to access them, and whether every single person needs access to every single work. Your analysis is way too simplistic for this conversation.
- 7y ago
- beyourself911 7y agoIf you sold your TV I bet you’d have something to talk about.
- barkerja 7y agoI don't know if I'd go as far to say it's worse. Cable forced one's hand into paying for things they didn't necessarily want. At least with this model, we the consumer have the ability to pick and choose exactly what we want to pay for. If a network has shows that look appealing to you, subscribe for a couple months. If there's only one show that looks appealing, buy it on iTunes. We're never going to have an affordable, legal, pay-once-for-everything model.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> We're never going to have an affordable, legal, pay-once-for-everything model. That possibility is a huge market failure. The demand is there.
- jeromegv 7y agoHow can you have access to all content while keeping it affordable? Cable was “everything” but it wasn’t affordable. Movie and TV Content is expensive to produce, can’t have it all for $10/month.
- unlinked_dll 7y ago>How can you have access to all content while keeping it affordable Media companies could stop over pricing their content
- anoncake 7y agoThe marginal cost of watching something is neglible. The only reasonable outcome is everyone being able to access everything, anything else is a huge market failure.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> How can you have access to all content while keeping it affordable? For the same total amount of content produced, they could give everyone access to all of it for the same total revenue they receive now and the only thing that would change is that everyone would have access to all of it. You don't make more money by having only 20% of the customers even if it means you don't have to share the revenue with four other studios. You make less, because having access to some of the content isn't worth as much as having access to all of the content, so the industry as a whole is providing less value and consequently doing less business.
- throwaway1777 7y agoSo you want more regulation? You mean like the monopoly cable industry regulations? You think breaking up Disney is the answer? Then you have 10 streaming services to subscribe to instead of 5
- wolco 7y ago90%? Disney doesn't really own a lot. They have huge brands in some niches but overall not much % wise. They refuse to touch anything adult in nature and that is the vast majority of content.
- dehrmann 7y agoDisney used to own Miramax so it could release R films without tarnishing the main brand.
- amayne 7y agoDisney created Touchstone for this purpose in the 1980s. Disney bought Miramax in the 1990s and as far as I know, they never used Miramax to release a Disney Studios-originated property. I could be wrong.
- redis_mlc 7y ago> Disney doesn't really own a lot. The scene has changed in the past decade. They're one of the largest US media conglomerates now.
- nostromo 7y agoNo, it’s much better than cable. Most people don’t watch that much TV and won’t need more than one or two services. Those people are saving a ton of money. And a few people that are glued to their TVs will pay more. As they should. I’m particularly happy that I no longer have to subsidize sports, which I never watched, to the tune of $20 a month or so.
- didibus 7y agoAgreed, and people forget that you are not locked into contracts for any of them. That's the killer. Alternate them as you see fit, don't need to have them all at once. And since they all allow you to watch what you want when you want it, it's more like choosing a show to watch every month and paying only for that by subscribing for that service only for that month.
- mrfusion 7y agoProblem is if you want one show from each service.
- CharlesW 7y agoWhat do you think of this solution? (1) Sign up for a month, (2) binge, (3) cancel.
- mrfusion 7y agoGood idea except I don’t like phoning up companies to cancel.
- TrunkleBob 7y agoI've canceled (and later resubscribed) to Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon without ever picking up the phone.
- echelon 7y agoThis is easy now. Just wait until retention starts hurting their bottom line.
- scarface74 7y agoYet another post on HN about a company that needs to be broken up because they are big in some made up market. Now are we going to define a monopoly as the “Pop Culture” market. Would you also like the government to “build a market” so that everyone can have all the software they want and have the government decide what a fair amount for software is?
- echelon 7y agoDisney films are generic, cookie cutter formulas designed for mass appeal and ROI. They buy everything they can and then force theaters to show their films in the most desirable weekend spots. They're soaking up all the money and pushing the smaller players out. They're now trying to eat Netflix. Not to mention that they follow Beijing's content directives. We should take a serious look at balancing the scales. If we expired Star Wars' copyright after 20 years, others could use the license and develop their own take. Disney would be forced to innovate and pursue new IP creation. It would be good for competition. This is just my own thought on the matter. Maybe it's wrong. I happen to think it would improve the status quo and actually result in market growth as you'd need new to hire more creatives. Novel content in turn results in more interest.
- scarface74 7y agoEvery commercial product is designed for maximum ROI. They buy everything they can and then force theaters to show their films in the most desirable weekend spots. You really think movie theaters would rather show movies that don’t fill it? They're soaking up all the money and pushing the smaller players out. Ever heard of Blumhouse? Their entire business model is to make low budget movies that cost under $10 million and they usually have a higher ROI than Disney movies. If we expired Star Wars' copyright after 20 years, others could use the license and develop their own take. Disney would be forced to innovate and pursue new IP creation. It would be good for competition. Why not force other people to innovate instead of building on top of Star Wars?
- echelon 7y ago
- basch 7y ago>Now we're going to have to pay more AND switch between nine different apps with broken UIs. Roku, Fire, Apple all make it easy to search and browse for a show and then deep link into the correct app. It's not perfect, and I hope it will get better, but you are not currently forced to open the apps. Fire goes a step further and lets you play videos you are licensed to right out of the fire interface, without the app firing up. It's easy to subscribe to hbo, cbs ets and have the content you are licensed to see show up right with your other stuff. (The Fire interface being not so pleasant to use is another story entirely.) >Disney needs to be broken up. They own 90% of American pop culture. Has a company ever been broken up for its library of content? >build services like Spotify that have everything and merely pay the rights holders. These platforms above are the single aggregator you are looking for. Comcast and DirecTV were these, but without the option for a la cart. >pay way less than cable. You have the option to make it cheaper if you want to rotate your subscriptions and not hold them all at the same time. I see that as a net gain vs the previous status quo of the TV Provider bundle era.
- anoncake 7y ago> Has a company ever been broken up for its library of content? There's a first time for everything.
- Shorel 7y agoYou can't do binge-watching with cable. This is the fundamental difference here. You can subscribe to one service, binge all you want, change to another, and so on.
- echelon 7y ago> You can subscribe to one service, binge all you want, change to another, and so on. That is such a headache. Are you calling this a feature? What about those with ADHD that struggle to pay bills on time and never cancel gym memberships? How's that going to work out for them?