4 ms·
Money quote: "Project Trident will rebasing with Void Linux." Which is... fascinating. Switching out upstreams is one thing, but they're switching kernels in t
by yjftsjthsd-h 7y ago
Money quote: "Project Trident will rebasing with Void Linux."
Which is... fascinating. Switching out upstreams is one thing, but they're switching kernels in the process!
EDIT: more comments from finishing reading:
Looks like they do broadly intend to work with the Void upstream, so I'm quite pleased (as a Void user) that there will hopefully be more people contributing, especially on the musl branch.
> We will not be creating a migration path from the FreeBSD-based Project Trident to the new Void-based version. Please be prepared to copy your user data (/home/*) to a temporary location like a removable drive before installing the new version and copying the data back.
That's quite unfortunate. In particular, if they do integrate ZFS into Void including boot environments, there shouldn't be any reason they can't do it in place; just install into new filesystems and mount the old `tank/usr/home` as though nothing had happened. Unfortunately you would still lose direct binary compatibility, since Linux doesn't have a FreeBSD personality to use, but I don't see why you should need a new pool or home.
- turndown 7y agoIMO a migration path between kernels would be expecting too much out of an OSS project, but maybe I just have lower expectations for these things.
- mysterydip 7y agoIt's probably not a matter of technical capability to implement, rather lacking the support staff to handle all the requests they get when edge case users have a failed migration.
- red_phone 7y agoI think they’re trying to get around this by explicitly saying there will be no migration path, but it’ll be interesting to see whether they actually get away with that.
- cwyers 7y agoThey are a niche distribution of a niche distribution of one of the BSDs. They are moving to being a downstream of the 40th most popular Linux distribution by DistroWatch's measures. What is there to get away with? I suspect most of the people using this are the ones making this decision. https://www.distrowatch.com/dwres.php?resource=popularity https://www.distrowatch.com/dwres.php?resource=popularity
- bitwize 7y agoMeanwhile, Microsoft provided the ability to migrate between kernels in the early 90s.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoMoney is the magic that makes everything possible:) The true irony to me is that they probably could support it if they were going the other direction, since FreeBSD does have a Linux-compatible personality. Actually, you might still be able to leverage that going the other way... release X is based on FreeBSD, release X+1 uses the FreeBSD kernel but migrates to Void Linux userland complete with actual Linux ELF binaries and can still run FreeBSD binaries, release X+2 switches to just running the Void Linux binaries on a Linux kernel, and only moving one release at a time is supported. It'd just be an insane amount of work.
- cjbprime 7y ago> Which is... fascinating. Switching out upstreams is one thing, but they're switching kernels in the process Switching kernel can actually be a pretty small thing compared to switching distribution! I remember using Debian/FreeBSD, Debian userland on top of a FreeBSD kernel. For most people, I bet switching away from BSD to GNU userland would be a bigger deal than moving from the FreeBSD to Linux kernel.