3 ms·
The success of the wild salmon isn’t just down to a “hardy upbringing”, though; it mostly comes down to the fact that, for every one wild adult salmon we see, t
by derefr 7y ago
The success of the wild salmon isn’t just down to a “hardy upbringing”, though; it mostly comes down to the fact that, for every one wild adult salmon we see, there are thousands that died (probably by being eaten) as eggs or fry. That’s a huge selection pressure toward inclusive genetic fitness, such that genetic fitness in the wild population as a whole is maintained at a high level over generations.
I’m not sure there’s really a way to translate that effect to human beings in any ethical way, regardless of how you feel about safety. It’d go well beyond “not coddling.” (In fact, I’m not even sure if it’s possible for an apex predator to be R-selected. We’d likely have to do it ourselves, Battle Royale style.)
- mr-ron 7y agoGenetic or upbringing? Not clear which is accounting for the Salmon study here
- lainga 7y agoWell, if civilisation ever collapses, I guess we'd get something out of it
- chibg10 7y agoUnfortunately though, whatever natural selection that occurs in a post-civilization world is might be sort of orthogonal to improving human civilization when civilization returns. We’d surely get some beastly hunter-gatherers out of the deal though :)
- Buge 7y ago>I’m not sure there’s really a way to translate that effect to human beings in any ethical way, regardless of how you feel about safety. It's unclear to me what you would want to select for. Being physically fit? Being smart? Being motivated? Being ethical? Being friendly?
- bnjms 7y agoIt’s not clear at all. I think we’d instead select against undesirable traits. If intelligence and fitness are too varied to select for we could select against lack of intelligence or lack of physical fitness. Say I’ve had cancer at a young age I’m out but we can’t decide on body type. I can’t even imagine how to avoid antisocial behavior, which is fine since any attempt at this Is dystopian.
- LilBytes 7y agoAll of the above.
- chrischen 7y agoThey are certainly fit to survive in the wild, but a farm is more likely to raise the Stephen Hawking of Salmon. Fit is relative, and surviving well in the wild is just as arbitrary as surviving well in in s farmZ
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]