3 ms·
Your lay explanation doesn't account for some important fundamentals - like the subtle distinctions between the different historic tunings, the fact that pure e
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Your lay explanation doesn't account for some important fundamentals - like the subtle distinctions between the different historic tunings, the fact that pure equal temperament is only really a thing on electronic instruments, the need for stretch tuning on some acoustic instruments but not others, the origins of the melodic minor, the harmonic minor, and the modes, the use of the dissonant major second in many folk musics around the world... and that's not even getting into the complications of composing in different styles.
It's not technically wrong to say that equal temperament is based on the 12th root of 2. But it's also not a complete description of real world tunings, especially in acoustic performance.
Generally, math turns out to be a bad way to understand music. There are elements in music that look like math, but the similarities turn out to be superficial and massively oversimplified. If you take them too literally you run into serious conceptual problems almost immediately.
In fact the defining feature of music is that it always slips through any simple bounded conceptual model. Music simply isn't simple. That's what makes it so interesting.