4 ms·
The article is right on that Zuckerberg when giving interviews doesn't seem to be able to articulate what the company's policies are, how they fit into legal fr
by Barrin92 7y ago
The article is right on that Zuckerberg when giving interviews doesn't seem to be able to articulate what the company's policies are, how they fit into legal frameworks, what the response would be if the model of the company was fundamentally broken, and so on.
This was really apparent in the interview he did with Yuval Noah Harari. When Harari asked him what would happen if "connecting the world" wasn't actually a positive thing, Zuckerberg didn't really have a coherent answer other then going on about how free expression is always great and how it's in the American constitution or whatever.
That's something that I've noticed when a lot of these CEOs are interviewed or when one reads their books. You expect to encounter some profound insight but it is surprising how shallow, uneducated and out of their depth these people are when it comes to placing their companies in some historical or political context. It's like they've done nothing but trying to make money to the point where they've forgotten why they're doing anything, a bunch of facile PR slogans aside. No self-awareness, no reflection, no ability to consider the broad impact of their behaviour. The most philosophical you're going to get is likely a tract on the AI apocalypse.
- hos234 7y agoHe is basically the John Hammond character in Jurassic Park. He will continue to cling to his creation well after the power goes out, the kids are missing and the Raptors and T-Rex are loose. Only problem is he hasn't been running this experiment on an island but on 2 billion lab rats. Whether they are Generals, Janitors, Journalists or Teenagers everyone is effected in ways no one fully understands yet. So now we wait for more and more unintended consequences to mount. Because it's not like a Zuckerberg replacement is going to do any better. This is a problem that has only one solution. Eventually the park will be shut down and be rebuilt after we understand the psychological and sociological dynamics such networks produces at scale. Right now his answer to Harari is incoherent because no one knows what the answer is. And it's impossible to figure it out while watching the current experiment gone of the rails. Micheal Crichton however, did provide a possible answer to Harari's question 20 years ago - "I think cyberspace means the end of our species. It means the end of innovation. This idea that the whole world is wired together is mass death. Every biologist knows that small groups in isolation evolve fastest. You put a thousand birds on an ocean island and they'll evolve very fast. You put ten thousand on a big continent, and their evolution slows down. Now, for our own species, evolution occurs mostly through our behaviour. We innovate new behaviour to adapt. And everybody on earth knows that innovation only occurs in small groups. Put three people on a committee and they may get something done. Ten people, and it gets harder. Thirty people, and nothing happens. Thirty million, it becomes impossible. That's the effect of mass media - it keeps anything from happening. Mass media swamps diversity. It makes every place the same. Bangkok or Tokyo or London: there's a McDonald's on one corner, a Benetton on another, a Gap across the street. Regional differences vanish. All differences vanish. In a mass-media world, there's less of everything except the top ten books, records, movies, ideas. People worry about losing species diversity in the rain forest. But what about intellectual diversity - our most necessary resource? That's disappearing faster than trees. But we haven't figured that out, so now we're planning to put five billion people together in cyberspace. And it'll freeze the entire species. Everything will stop dead in its tracks. Everyone will think the same thing at the same time. Global uniformity"
- ryanmarsh 7y agoEveryone will think the same thing at the same time. Global uniformity This seems like it would be a dream come true for a totalitarian regime or modern aristocracy thriving on the control of its subjects.
- K0SM0S 7y agoI don't share your pessimism, but you do make a very interesting point, or diagnosis. There are other evolutionary traits to consider: bigger groups of animals do not necessarily correlate with better communication, hence economic/evolutionary friction (loss of efficiency). We're in a different situation where no one moved but everyone got connected, maybe this will let adaptation (good evolutionary traits and genes) spread faster across the species, or boost their completeness faster in time. Who knows. It's impossible to predict evolution at this stage, especially ours. These warnings should be considered and taken into account, but not impede our drive to improve. On a deeper political note, I and it seems more and more people seem to envision the idea of a much more granular organization and tiered, i.e. instead of 250 countries with average 30 million people, allow for much more diversity at a 1-10 million scale, and form meta blocks of ~1 billion to manage world affairs more easily. With a 'true' bottom-up democracy, this would allow much diversity at a local scale (geographically, but we can already imagine some of these few million-people groups being almost entirely online). That's 1 possible and desirable scenario for political evolution in this century IMHO (15 years of research in that domain lead me to this conclusion; there are other likely scenarios obviously).
- kthejoker2 7y agoI mean, how crazy wrong is this prediction though? The web has increased diversity (good and bad) through scale and virality and lower than ever barriers to entry to the market of mindshare. The monoculture is practically dead. Fringe media is rampant. Microinfluencers abound. Filter bubbles are omnipresent. The long tail has exploded thanks to global supply chains and the TFE.
- luckylion 7y agoSince it's usually not the CEOs that spectacularly and completely failed and don't get up again are writing those books, they may also simply start drinking their own kool-aid. If you talk about how you are X, even if you started doing that knowing it isn't true and only to mislead the public, you're probably find rationalizations that say you really are X and your brain no longer has to simulate two competing realities to allow you to function at your job. The power of positive thinking weaponized and run on a well oiled machine of ad creators that can absolutely make you believe that you are solving the world's problem.
- Mirioron 7y agoI don't think those CEOs can answer those types of questions. Some of these types of questions seem to just be gotchas, where engaging with the question at all leads to a bad outcome. Any kind of public deliberation on "well, what if your company just fails/is evil" could negatively impact how well the company does. Why would a CEO even tempt fate like this? If the world wasn't so keen on taking sound bites out of context, then maybe you could have CEOs give you meaningful answers about these questions in interviews. But the world does love their sound bites and thus the only thing they can say is PR-speak.
- goalieca 7y agoHe’s not able to refute the premise of the question. So.. not really a gotcha.
- Mirioron 7y agoThese types of questions are gotchas because any kind of refutation is going to include complex reasoning. You can't present those kinds of answers, because media organizations will just pick and choose their soundbites from it. You'll be the bad guy regardless what the answer is as long as you try to seriously answer the question. Imagine having a discussion about abortion where the other party can ask whatever contrived question they want and somebody will later pick and choose soundbites from your answers. What's the chance that you can properly defend your position without giving away soundbites that can make you sound like a lunatic? I think it's very low. You instead say something along the lines of "That is what I believe because we should respect X's rights" and then shift the topic slightly. That's what these CEOs are doing.
- bko 7y ago> if "connecting the world" wasn't actually a positive thing That's the most baffling part. Facebook is a closed platform, so they're not "connecting the world". They set the terms and rules. So I don't know how he is supposed to answer that. Because he's connecting the world, but in a way that has rules and boundaries about what speech is allowed. So he's getting complaints on both sides, people that want it more open and less open. The pro-open ones don't like the control Facebook has and its size. The pro-closed ones don't like hate groups or politicians of one party or another on the platform. And of course some people for whatever reason just don't like him personally, in which case facebook could never win
- zelphirkalt 7y agoYou are quite spot-on with: > No self-awareness, no reflection, no ability to consider the broad impact of their behaviour. And as much as Zuckerberg is bad, I have to say, that this is true for many more people than just people, who are CEOs. I have the feeling, that this applies to the majority of the population by now. In combination with Facebook for these people it means, that whatever gets likes must be a good thing, as determined by "the community", no matter what the actual impact may be. It is even sadder, that we already had philosophical works, which usually people learn in school about, but don't seem to actually understand, that they should think about them and perhaps apply them or parts of them to how they live. They just don't care and choose to remain ignorant. What about the categorical imperative of Kant? If you live in Germany you ought to know about it! How often do people ask themselves, if what they are doing is the right thing to do these days, using tools like the categorical imperative or any other philosophical theory, that someone from the past has put years into coming up with? I am not saying "take this theory and apply 100% of it to your life". But people should think about their actions from time to time. Is Zuckerberg even aware, that his company had to pay the highest amount of cash _ever_ for privacy violations?!
- ecf 7y agoWell a great majority of the CEOs I’ve worked under were in the office maybe 1-2 times a quarter. Maybe they can’t articulate it because they legitimately are disconnected from from the company they founded?