3 ms·
Thanks for the article. I wonder if he's a Buddhist? Most of the way through he seems to be making the case that consciousness and will are illusory, and that
by denton-scratch 7y ago
Thanks for the article.
I wonder if he's a Buddhist?
Most of the way through he seems to be making the case that consciousness and will are illusory, and that we are indistinguishable from mechanisms. But towards the end, he seems to allow that we can take measures to improve our decision-making abilities.
My interpretation of Buddhist psychology is that, for the most part, our behaviour (decision-making) is the result of "causes and conditions", i.e. our actions are generally not "voluntary"; but that we can nevertheless, through introspection and practice, improve our understanding and decision-making.
I think his poker-bot needs an "introspection circuit" to oversee and direct the learning process. I do not accept his contention that poker-bots demonstrate that deep-learning/AI can ever model a conscious mind without such a circuit.
[Edit: I spent several decades studying Buddhism; I returned to an uncompromising rationalism about 10 years ago, and I'm much better now. Doesn't that suggest that people can change their minds?]
- bufferoverflow 7y agoDefinitely sounds like a religious person trying to argue against logic and reason... using logic and reason. He is not the first, he won't be the last.
- denton-scratch 7y agoOh. My interpretation was more-or-less diametrically opposite; I took it that he was a committed mechanist, arguing that the mind is a machine (he's a neurologist); and trying to deal with the (personal and unverifiable) experience of being conscious and having what seems to be will.
- spicymaki 7y agoFrom a traditional Buddhist perspective free will is necessary. If everything was predetermined, the entire path of practice to freedom from suffering would be pointless. However the past karma has an large influence on the present and cannot be ignored.
- denton-scratch 7y agoI thought that it was karma that led to your being born in an age in which a Buddha had existed, karma that led to you encountering the teachings, karma that led to you being able to become a monk, karma that led to your introduction to a teacher, and karma that led to your success in your practice. Nearly everything about the path is determined by karma, no? But all of that kind of karma results from kind (or skillful) actions, and I think the idea is that those moral/immoral actions have to be deliberate, to have any impact on your karma. The way I heard it, most actions that bear at all karma, only bear on karma for this life; actions that create heavy-lifting, multi-life karma are rare. See why I think the guy might be a Buddhist?
- gerbilly 7y agoThe entire practise of Buddhism requires free will. Without free will, it would be impossible to follow the eightfold path. You may be thinking that karma predetermines all our behaviour. This is a false view that the Buddha specifically denied. Our current state, and our current actions are determined by a combination of past conditioning (karma) and our will/intentions in the current moment. You could think of it as a function with two main input streams. Because it's recursive (past will/intentions feeds back in as karma) it makes the trajectory nonlinear, which is why it's such a difficult path to navigate.
- denton-scratch 7y agoAs I indicated, I am no longer a Buddhist; one reason is that the karma/rebirth story was completely unconvincing to me (karma makes no sense without rebirth). I am convinced by the multiple experimental demonstrations that decisions seem to occur before any cerebral "act of will" can be detected; and the baseball batter story is a nice thought experiment. It's deeply counter-intuitive; the only way I can grok it is that most of what seems to be free will is just observation of "what you were just thinking". But the belief that we have some measure of control is very hard to get rid of. I like the "nonlinear" characterization.
- gerbilly 7y agoNot trying to convert you back to Buddhism, but if that's you only objection, I have to tell you Karma does not require rebirth. In fact the Buddha refused to respond one way or another when asked what happens to us after death.¹ Karma can be seen as operating from moment to moment. It's easier to think of it as 'past conditions', i.e. the initial conditions that led to our current state. This applies physically as well as psychologically. If you like the image of non-linearity, see². 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_unanswered_questions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_unanswered_questions 2: https://www.dhammatalks.org/books/KarmaOfQuestions/Section0009.html https://www.dhammatalks.org/books/KarmaOfQuestions/Section00...