3 ms·
Ask HN: Why doesn't the USA have a great car insurance comparison site?
I recently (2 weeks ago) moved to San Francisco, and am excited to be here. But lots of things seem backward compared to places I've lived before (UK, China).
In particular: I was looking for car insurance last week. I left the UK in 2010, and even then there was more than one car insurance comparison site that showed firm quotations from many insurers. So I only ever had to fill in two forms: one on the comparison site, and another on whichever insurer turned out to be cheapest.
Perhaps I'm just missing something, but I haven't found anything similar in the US. I found a couple of comparison sites, but:
- instead of asking for all the information needed for underwriting, they ask for <10 pieces of info, AND
- instead of returning a sortable list of quotations from multiple companies, they return a list of insurance companies and indicative price ranges. To get actual quotations, I need to visit each individual site and fill in each individual application form.
I must be missing something: either this exists and I just didn't find it, or there's some structural reason why no one has started (or succeeding in building) a proper comparison site that does something similar to the UK's Money Supermarket.
Curious to hear from anyone working in auto insurance or who has looked at this problem.