regarding 1. I think people can be convinced without shaming. Pardon the generic example. If people do X, then Y happens. Y is a bad thing because A,B and C. ve

regarding 1. I think people can be convinced without shaming. Pardon the generic example. If people do X, then Y happens. Y is a bad thing because A,B and C. versus If you do X, you are bad person and are directly responsible for Y and it's effects A,B and C. Both offer similar information, but the latter can produce resentment and irrational backlash. Regarding 2. I confess I am at a loss at how to get government to take useful action. Have you seen a politician successfully shamed lately? It might be happening but it is not making headlines.