11 ms·
The U.S. spends $3.5 trillion annually on healthcare. Worldwide profits for the 112 publicly traded healthcare industry companies amount to $50 billion per quar
by rayiner 7y ago
The U.S. spends $3.5 trillion annually on healthcare. Worldwide profits for the 112 publicly traded healthcare industry companies amount to $50 billion per quarter: https://www.thefiscaltimes.com/2018/11/12/Chart-Day-Big-Pharmas-Profits https://www.thefiscaltimes.com/2018/11/12/Chart-Day-Big-Phar.... Even if all those profits are allocated to the U.S., that's about 5.7% of healthcare spending. (And completely consistent with most other industries.)
Hyper-focusing on profits is misguided. Many countries with costs much lower than ours have for-profit hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, etc. Public operation of the health system would surely eliminate the profit, but why do we have reason to believe it will reduce the other $3.3 billion? We can point to European countries that have much lower costs overall, but those countries seem to provide many public services at much lower cost than we do (education, transit, etc.). Canada's government expenditures (excluding defense for both countries), is somehow slightly lower than the U.S., even though Canada offers universal healthcare.
The public rhetoric frustrates me as someone who favors universal healthcare. Demonizing corporations and rich people is red meat for partisans, but it’s not a solution. How do we pay for this system? How do we cut costs? Making healthcare into a public service in the US risks turning into the same thing we have with education, transit, and infrastructure. We spend tons of money, often more than European countries, and get very little in return. And the only solutions folks offer are to dismantle the public system (on the right), or to demand even more funding (on the left).
- abrichr 7y agoIn 2017 (from https://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Statistics-Trends-and-Reports/NationalHealthExpendData/NationalHealthAccountsHistorical.html https://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Sta...): Hospital Care (33 percent share) Physician and Clinical Services (20 percent share) Retail Prescription Drugs (10 percent share) Other Health, Residential, and Personal Care Services (5 percent share) Nursing Care Facilities and Continuing Care Retirement Communities (5 percent share) Dental Services (4 percent share) Home Health Care (3 percent share) Other Professional Services (3 percent share) Other Non-durable Medical Products (2 percent share) Durable Medical Equipment (2 percent share)
- megiddo 7y agoWhat a strangely factual response on this forum.
- edm0nd 7y agoHN is a lot better and level headed than places like reddit.
- kshacker 7y agoHmmm. What is profit? If a company pays its CEO 10 million dollars, it is not stated profit, but that's a cost we could live without. If a CEO can write off a few million, a few 10s of millions in corporate gala spending, it is not stated profit, but that's a cost we could live without. I am sure if we dig deeper into cost per patient between Medicare and between lets pick a company, you will realize that you can do without maybe 20% of this 3.5 trillion easily. And that is before we start looking at many other factors such as abuses in the system (looking from the other side and looking at freeloaders to say it very bluntly and quickly). While I look at the CEO's multi-million salary, I also wonder how much tax they pay. Did the 10 million salary lead to 3-3.5 million in taxes or ... we probably can guess the answer. It is a double / triple whammy. Message: Look at the total loot, not the stated profit.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DonnyV 7y agoFirst of all I don't trust profit numbers of any large corporation. There are so many ways that large corporations can hide profit. So lets pay attention to revenue. UnitedHealth alone generated $200 billion in 2017. https://www.modernhealthcare.com/article/20180116/NEWS/180119932/unitedhealth-revenue-cracks-200-billion-mark https://www.modernhealthcare.com/article/20180116/NEWS/18011... Yeah there might be some fat there.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThere is at most 20% of "fat" there, by law (ACA).
- AimForTheBushes 7y agoAssuming your distrust is true then the article's point of attacking profits is futile.
- awinder 7y agoSo there’s the profits, and there’s the costs of the profit system. Which is why you have to look in places like administrative costs which are something like 17% in private insurance. Profit is the money over revenue - costs, so yes the profit is a center of waste, but there’s a ton of waste in the costs department that would not be necessary in a universal system. There’s also a lot of makework jobs wrapped in there too, so it’s no doubt a complicated problem.
- tptacek 7y agoBy the numbers you just cited --- higher than the numbers I found, but only by single digits --- if you zeroed out administrative costs, eliminating not just insurance but any money paid anywhere to administer health benefits --- you would bring the cost of a low-deductible family health plan down by about $100/month. That is simply not enough, not nearly enough, to address the problem. Our national health care problem is not that plans cost $100 too much.
- awinder 7y agoI mean I'm at 20% in 2 cost centers (ill give you back 3 single digits but not a digit more), and there's more math on how you actually save money in a single payer system than just those 2 things. I don't know where the average family low-deductible plan costs $500 (maybe with employer subsidies? again, not a fair comparison), but 20% is a lot more than the 5% the parent discussed.
- tptacek 7y agoI'm going to hold you to your own 17% number just to keep things simple. In Chicago, for a family of four, the lowest-priced ACA bronze plan, Blue Cross with a restricted network ("FocusCare") and a $15,000 family deductible, after zeroing out 17% of expenses, you are paying $976/mo. I think health insurance is very valuable, but can say confidently that the average family in Chicago does not view $976/mo with a $15k deductible and a limited network as "affordable". The numbers get even harder if you select a more reasonable plan.
- ivraatiems 7y agoThe problem is not the raw number for how much profit is made; it's how much waste is generated in pursuit of that profit. For example, the entire concept of "negotiated rates" as they apply to the US healthcare system is based around various entities trying to maximize profit, rather than maximize provision of care.[1][2][3] This results in patients being stuck with enormous bills, and services not being provided, or being provided at unreasonable costs. And this is just one area where this is the case. Costs for prescription drugs (especially new/non-generic ones) are another great example. Because of the system's desire for profit, much of that $3.5 trillion is being spent to try to pump up that $50 billion -- and it's not even doing a particularly good job, as you note yourself, since other nations with for-profit systems have much lower costs. I'm not saying that no for-profit system could exist that wouldn't be better. But whether that theoretical new system is for-profit or not-for-profit (or, as it most likely would be, a hybrid as we see in many developed countries), we'd have to rip out a substantial amount of the current system to get it. [1] https://www.policygenius.com/health-insurance/what-is-a-negotiated-rate/ https://www.policygenius.com/health-insurance/what-is-a-nego... [2] https://www.americanprogress.org/press/release/2019/06/26/471491/release-new-report-shows-hospitals-raise-prices-private-insurance/ https://www.americanprogress.org/press/release/2019/06/26/47... (note: American Progress is a liberal-skewed source, but their stats should be good) [3] https://www.bu.edu/questrom/2018/12/04/insurers-negotiated-rates-can-dramatically-affect-health-care-prices/ https://www.bu.edu/questrom/2018/12/04/insurers-negotiated-r...
- tptacek 7y agoNegotiated cartel rates and lack of price insurance sure do seem like a plausible component of our health care debacle. But other countries have for-profit providers and private insurance and they don't have these problems. Why is that? The prescription drug market is dysfunctional. But what did the last breakdown you look at say about the percentage of our health dollars swallowed by prescription drugs, compared to caregiver salaries, hospital procedures, and long-term care costs?
- ivraatiems 7y ago> Negotiated cartel rates and lack of price insurance sure do seem like a plausible component of our health care debacle. But other countries have for-profit providers and private insurance and they don't have these problems. Why is that? I'm reading your question as slightly rhetorical. If that's the case, and you have some thoughts, you should share them. For my part, I'd start by looking at the way other privatized systems are managed and regulated, such as Sweden's: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2012/dec/18/private-healthcare-lessons-from-sweden https://www.theguardian.com/society/2012/dec/18/private-heal... > But what did the last breakdown you look at say about the percentage of our health dollars swallowed by prescription drugs, compared to caregiver salaries, hospital procedures, and long-term care costs? I'm not making the point that prescription drugs are the largest or even a particularly substantial contributor to the overall number. I'm arguing they're an easy-to-see example of the overall problems that most facets of the current system face. (By the way, the breakdown another user higher in the chain posted puts prescription drugs at 10% of overall costs, so that's a big chunk.)
- claudeganon 7y ago> The public rhetoric frustrates me as someone who favors universal healthcare. Demonizing corporations and rich people is red meat for partisans, but it’s not a solution. How do we pay for this system? How do we cut costs? There are already two pieces of legislation, the Jayapal and Sanders bills, they account for their costs. Tim Faust’s new book likewise walks through all of these concerns in detail: https://www.mhpbooks.com/books/health-justice-now/ https://www.mhpbooks.com/books/health-justice-now/ And I don’t think people are “demonizing” corporations, so much as they are being more and more exposed to fundamental cruelty and parasitism of the American healthcare system. As costs spiral out of control and inequality compounds in the US, a far greater swathe of people are finding themselves on the receiving end of its violence and deprivation. I’d suggest you look at the work of disability activists like Ady Barkan to get a better picture.
- rayiner 7y agoThe Sanders bill plans to pay for Medicare for All with taxes that are much lower than the social insurance taxes in France or Germany. That is pure fantasy. That gives me little comfort that its accurately accounting for costs.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> The Sanders bill plans to pay for Medicare for All with taxes that are much lower than the social insurance taxes in France or Germany. The US has much weaker non-healthcare social insurance than France or Germany, and a much larger per-capita economic activity to tax, so lower social insurance taxes for equivalent healthcare seems to be expected rather than suspicious.
- rayiner 7y agoFrance’s healthcare tax is 20%. Sanders’ proposal is about 14.4%. As to per capita economic activity—the assumption is that we’ll be as cost efficient as France in absolute dollar terms, not even just percentage of GDP terms? When we spend 30% more on primary education per student than France?
- darksaints 7y agoPublicly traded is a tiny fraction of the healthcare industry. Of the dozen or so hospitals in Seattle, for example, only one is owned by a publicly traded company. Even if they're technically non-profit, that doesn't mean they don't realize a profit. It just means that the profit needs to be spent elsewhere. This is model that most university medical centers use: make a shit ton of money in healthcare, and then use it on the school or pay fat paychecks to the board of directors. I think when people talk about profits they aren't talking about GAAP profits, they're talking about rent seeking. There is a shit ton of that everywhere. For example, when I went to the ER for a kidney stone at a non-profit hospital, I ended up getting 8 bills. One was from the hospital. Then I got one from the lab that ran the CT Scanner, one from the Radiologist that analyzed the ct scan, one from the pharmacy that provided the drugs I was given, and four bills from the four ER doctors making their rounds through the ER, asking how I was feeling, and then checking a box on the chart. Each 5 minute visit was rounded up to the hour. That's all "profit" in the colloquial sense, but it wouldn't show up in the P&L of a publicly traded company even if the organization was publicly traded.