6 ms·
In all honesty, with Metal limited to just Apple and Vulkan representing roughly “everyone else,” will this even be a fair fight? This could be a horrendous pre
by jchw 7y ago
In all honesty, with Metal limited to just Apple and Vulkan representing roughly “everyone else,” will this even be a fair fight? This could be a horrendous prediction, but I see Metal as the modern-day Betamax. There’s nothing wrong with it, but is this how you win a competition of APIs? I have enormous doubts.
- lostmsu 7y agoDoes Vulkan work on Xbox and PS?
- Grazester 7y agoTheir GPU's support it, of course they are closed systems so I have no idea how you would get it on there easily.
- jchw 7y agoExcellent question, but let’s be clear: it’s more of a question of whether or not Xbox or PlayStation ship Vulkan implementations. As far as I know, PlayStation is traditionally proprietary APIs, and you would need a third party implementation, if one exists. As for Xbox, I assume Xbox is still a modified Direct3D API for graphics. I assume you didn’t mention Switch because it, somewhat famously, does actually ship with Vulkan support natively. Which is cool. Of course, even though video game consoles continue to converge into looking like computers, developers still don’t and can’t treat them as such. Sure, Switch runs Vulkan but that doesn’t mean you can compile a Vulkan game and ship it to the eShop. Same for a DirectX game on Xbox. Consoles are, by nature, very proprietary, and much more frugal than general purpose computing platforms. Does adoption of Vulkan for game consoles matter? Maybe, but I’d guess probably not. It might help the consoles attract developers, but at the end of the day every console is going to get its own port with a decent amount of retooling to better suit the platform, especially in the case of Switch which is not a terribly high end piece of hardware in this day and age.
- pjmlp 7y agoSwitch also has their own proprietary API, NVN. Vulkan is a kind of addendum.
- jchw 7y agoSure: it’s clear Vulkan is made to attract developers. I don’t think there’s any delusion that a unified API would really mean you didn’t have to port to each console individually; you need more fine grained optimization for most games still, especially in Switch’s case. Eventually this may stop being true, but as long as a $300 laptop has trouble gaming, it would be unfair to expect a $300 portable game console to run unmodified games significantly better. In this case, the API only matters to a smaller degree.
- gdubs 7y agoSome form of this argument has been a criticism of Apple from time immemorial.
- m463 7y agoAt first it was apple's way or the highway. Then apple started integrating well with everyone. They adopted intel cpus. Apple hardware let you have your cake and eat it too - you could run Mac OS or Windows or both. You could buy a system with intel, or ati (amd) or nvidia. You could put hard disks or ssds in your machine. You had choices. Mac laptops became the laptops that everyone wanted. Now they're going back the other way.
- gok 7y agoFor deep learning, scientific computing, basically all other GPGPU stuff, it's all (>95%) CUDA. Vulkan is essentially unused.
- jchw 7y agoNo doubt. In fact this is still true for virtually all GPGPU compute as far as I know. It’s possible Vulkan Compute will never gain serious traction, and it will remain CUDA vs the world. I kind of hope not for sake of open standards.
- Xixi 7y agoIn the context of this article, “everyone else” is CUDA. I think at this stage we can all agree that OpenCL has pretty much lost. While it is entirely possible that Vulkan will eventually manage to overtake all, has it even been making a dent in CUDA's market share so far? That said, given Apple's hardware cost, I don't think Metal will make a big dent either.
- jchw 7y agoI don’t think Vulkan Compute has really taken off at all. But, I suspect it still has a chance to do so if it manages to continue to gain mindshare as a graphics API. That really remains to be seen.
- pjmlp 7y agoVulkan is definitely not “everyone else”. On Windows it is only supported on classical Win32, on Win32 and UWP sandboxes only DirectX is supported. XBox naturally is DirectX only. On Sony PS4 there is LibGNM and doesn't appear PS 5 team will care about Vulkan. Nintendo Switch does support Vulkan, as secondary 3D API, if you want to go full speed, there is NVN for that. On Android, Google was forced to make Vulkan a required API on Android 10, because since its introduction as optional 3D API, outside Samsung and Google very few OEMs cared to ship good working Vulkan drivers, if at all. It is so significant that Google is yet to add Vulkan market share information to the Android dashboard.
- jchw 7y agoVulkan is “everyone else” if we’re only considering serious contenders for a next generation graphics and compute API. Machine-specific APIs don’t have a long shelf life, pretty much never have. DirectX does compete but it’s even further behind than Apple in terms of ecosystem coverage. Is anyone using DirectCompute? And also, UWP is practically dead in the water, no need to beat that horse. Game consoles are their own beast. It would be nice if they provided either Vulkan or GL, for porting lower tech software, but otherwise it’s unclear whether a generalized API would make sense in such a specialized device.
- pjmlp 7y agoUWP is pretty much alive. WinUI 3.0 and XAML Islands roadmap at BUILD 2019 https://mybuild.techcommunity.microsoft.com/sessions/77008 https://mybuild.techcommunity.microsoft.com/sessions/77008 React Native for Windows reimplementation https://github.com/microsoft/react-native-windows https://github.com/microsoft/react-native-windows React Native @ Microsoft, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IUMWFExtDSg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IUMWFExtDSg And even if one disregards the fact that all new Windows 10 APIs are UWP based, the sandbox also applies to Win32 apps deployed via the store or MSIX packages. As for DirectCompute, game developers naturally.
- jchw 7y agoDo we know marketshare of UWP games versus Steam and Epic Games Store? I realize anecdotes are worthless, but I know literally nobody that uses Windows Store to buy anything. If they had used it to buy books, they would already be SoL. Categorizing Windows Store as anything but a miserable option people use in any other condition than begrudgingly is a concept that is genuinely new to me, and I say this as someone that wanted to like Windows 10. Microsoft sent evangelists to my university twice while I was there in an attempt to push more developers towards UWP and the skepticism in the room was damn near palpable. To be fair, this was before UWP apps could run in windows without a Stardock utility (the Windows 8 era.) UWP is not new. I believe both Chromium and Firefox have attempted to support it and ultimately given up (correct me if I’m wrong.) It may be gaining a bit of developer traction now, but I don’t exactly see the world shifting around it, in a world where most apps are Electron and most games are on Steam, and pretty much everything else is “on the cloud.”