4 ms·
This is a pretty uncharitable comment friend... presumably you aren't the intended audience for this article. Anyway, you've never met anyone like this before?
by Gatsky 7y ago
This is a pretty uncharitable comment friend... presumably you aren't the intended audience for this article. Anyway, you've never met anyone like this before? I meet people like this all the time. They are much more interesting than those devoted to hyper-rational atheism AKA the Times New Roman of metaphysics. For one, these 'half-baked' types tend to be staggered by genuinely marvelous things, rather than just their perception of another person's incoherence.
- devilshaircut 7y agoIf "hyper-rational atheism" were the "Times New Roman of metaphysics", you'd think it would be far more common than it actually is. Going with your n=1 "I meet people like this all the time." theme, I know far more people of various religious flavors than I do atheists of any kind, "hyper-rational" or not.
- rkachowski 7y agoNo, I have never met a particle physicist that meditated his way into eating the notorious death cap and thanked god and spirituality for saving him. I find it pretty sad that you'd preclude rational people from being able to experience genuinely marvelous things. I can tell you that there is a whole spectrum of rational thought, including both your hyper rational and 'interesting' people. I don't think you actually believe that these people live a myopic life of sterile scrutiny and flavorless examination. The road is long my friend, and you have a distance to travel.
- Gatsky 7y agoYour original comment was drawing generalisations about a certain character of thought from one person's experience. Obviously, I am not asking if you have met another particle physicist with this specific set of eccentricities. Nor do I preclude anything about the scope or validity of someone's experiences, unlike your original comment.
- Apocryphon 7y ago"I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds."