3 ms·
It's pretty hilarious he thinks he is outside the reach of the five eyes agencies. Try this thought experiment. Find the top eight largest Icelandic ISPs' AS nu
by walrus01 7y ago
It's pretty hilarious he thinks he is outside the reach of the five eyes agencies. Try this thought experiment. Find the top eight largest Icelandic ISPs' AS numbers and IP space. Now look at who their BGP peers and transits are on both sides of the transatlantic submarine cables. And where those cables land.
- huangbong 7y agoTls
- andyjohnson0 7y agoThis map makes it clear: https://submarine-cable-map-2019.telegeography.com/ https://submarine-cable-map-2019.telegeography.com/ United States via Greenland, UK, Denmark.
- Spearchucker 7y agoThis is exactly why I moved my personal web site from the US to Germany and not to Iceland (which was my original plan). The thing of it was that GDPR provided better protection than no GDPR, and the cables negate any other benefit anyway. But this of course pre-dated the CLOUD act which could land you in jail for complying with either it or GDPR, as one requires you to share when asked, while the other prohibits it. Data protection needs a lot more work, and some precedents must be set for enforcing US law in Europe, and of course vice versa. Happily my server holds only my own data.
- briandear 7y agoYou moved your website because of Five Eyes? What kind of website is it?
- ceejayoz 7y ago“Our encrypted traffic transits the Five Eyes” and “the NSA/FBI can walk into our datacenter with a National Security Letter” are not comparable scenarios.
- walrus01 7y agoAs an ISP, I can tell you that actual implementation of national security letters is quite rare. If you're doing something you think might legitimately result in that sort of event, go buy server colocation physically located in Russia, not Iceland. There's a number of large Russian isps with good connectivity to the DE-CIX Frankfurt.
- ceejayoz 7y agoIsn't one of the core characteristics of a NSL that you can't tell us? It's also not the only attack model; it serves only as an example of the sort of power Five Eyes has within the five nations they wouldn't necessarily have in Iceland. Another example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A Colocating in Russia comes with its own issues.
- notyourday 7y ago> Colocating in Russia comes with its own issues. Enemy of my enemy... If you are afraid of a bogey men called Five Eyes and NSL, then colocating in Russia makes perfect sense. If you are a publisher of KavkazCenter, you should probably host it somewhere in the US.
- bob1029 7y agoI would be curious the issues with colocation in Russia. Judging by all of the potential issues with US/EU providers, it seems they may offer a certain class of comparative "safe haven" for particular types of applications. I.e. if it became illegal to say certain things about the US government, could I (an American citizen) hypothetically host my protest blog on a Russian provider and avoid prosecution?
- ceejayoz 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_Russia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_Russia Yes, you could probably safely criticize the US on a Russian-hosted blog, but in the scenario of a repeal of the First Amendment, I can't imagine the hosting location would save you from any theoretical prosecution.