2 ms·
Who decides if there is an issue? Who decides that the status quo is the absolute best situation? The answer to both of these questions is the same: establishe
by keiferski 7y ago
Who decides if there is an issue? Who decides that the status quo is the absolute best situation?
The answer to both of these questions is the same: established political and business interests.
If you believe in the political right of people to be self-governing, then I see no reason why you wouldn’t support any and all independence movements which sufficiently represent the populace. Of course, in order to minimize rash decisions, some restrictions might be necessary (e.g. only vote on the issue once a decade, when 85% of the population agrees, etc.)
Having said that, I can see other arguments which essentially say that forcing unification is ultimately beneficial for individual citizens, as larger states tend to have more power then smaller ones (i.e. unified Prussia was invaded far less than the loose confederation of German states.) But this seems a bit unlikely in the modern West; an independent Quebec or Scotland isn’t going to get invaded by its neighbors.