3 ms·
I...doubt that's an accurate characterization, because the things that you are describing lead to fragile software. Biological systems are hard to understand an
by perl4ever 7y ago
I...doubt that's an accurate characterization, because the things that you are describing lead to fragile software. Biological systems are hard to understand and to modify, but maybe that's more due to redundancy that has evolved than to systems that are coupled like bad software systems. After all, if they broke like buggy software, we wouldn't have so many diseases to study; living things would just crash and stop.
- hprotagonist 7y agoBiological systems mostly make up for the brittleness by being, if they survive, very redundant. You might be made up out of spaghetti code, but damn if we can't monkeypatch that shit on the fly!
- gbrown 7y agoThe above should be taken as an evocative analogy for the complexity and senselessness - don't go too far trying to apply your intuition about designed/engineered systems (even really bad fragile ones) to biology. The reason it's so crazy is that it's been evolving for billons of years - random mutations without one discernable iota of forethought or intention. The reason it works at all is that we're looking at the tiny fraction of accumulated changes that didn't die out. Evolution by natural selection builds crazy awesome, intricate things - just not sensibly engineered ones.
- hoseja 7y agoIt's extremely fragile, couple molecules of bad input and the whole thing comes crashing down!
- AllegedAlec 7y agoDo not doubt experts on this field. What he's saying is true. > Biological systems are hard to understand and to modify, but maybe that's more due to redundancy that has evolved than to systems that are coupled like bad software systems. No, it's not. It's all highly interconnected. There are no nice decoupled modules. If someone is showing you a module from biology which seems to have no interactions, he's leaving out information. The only reason biological systems are not as fragile (although they also are. E.S. Collizi did some interesting research on why) as you think is precisely because they are so interconnected and redundant. Furthermore, you seem to misunderstand why we don't see fragility. It's not because we get sick instead, but because nearly all of the nontrivial mutations are highly lethal, and the fetus dies in utero and you get a miscarriage. Most miscarriages happen so early the mother doesn't even notice.