2 ms·
Wow that's the sort of comment that usually gets removed. An unnecessary slur on an entire group of people with no supporting argument. Being disagreeable for t
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Wow that's the sort of comment that usually gets removed. An unnecessary slur on an entire group of people with no supporting argument. Being disagreeable for the sake of being disagreeable. I'm disappointed.
- tokai 7y agoYeah a really disparaging comment coming from a mod. What is the problem. Sure there is some bickering, but it's falling to the bottom.
- dang 7y agoA lot of bickering falls to the bottom because moderators downweight it. I wish that weren't so, because it's a lot of work.
- tokai 7y agoI'm sorry your comment confuses me. Isn't it us users that downweight comments with our votes? I thought you reacted on flags and heavy downvotes. I know you do a lions share of work dang, but I think you were a little to fast here. Good comments were being posted (and pushed below you comment) as you wrote that.
- dang 7y agoFor sure, users downweight (and up-weight!) comments. That's the most important factor. But moderators also downweight subthreads, for example if they're off topic. It's a combo of the two. Same for stories: the ranking is determined by votes, flags, software, and moderation. Users are the most important factor, but alas not a sufficient one. Without moderation, the system gets into unstable states and can't stay within its mandate. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 7y agoIt's partly strategic. The presence of a moderation comment like that in a thread often seems to evoke higher-quality comments. I'd bet that it such had an effect in this case—the thread improved almost immediately—but who knows. You're right that I should have written something longer and not in haste. But I'm a bit surprised by the strong reaction to that one; it's atypical. Perhaps to some readers it felt like a disparagement of their own view on religion—which of course it was not.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoSorry if I was catty. It was a bit of cold water in the face, is all. Personally I like to avoid such threads. You can't really be understood, whatever you contribute.
- dang 7y agoI don't think you were catty, and you were far from the only person who had an adverse reaction to my comment. I've learned something. So thanks!